CatBanter

CatBanter (http://www.catbanter.com/index.php)
-   Cat health & behaviour (http://www.catbanter.com/forumdisplay.php?f=5)
-   -   Science Diet question... (http://www.catbanter.com/showthread.php?t=14836)

PawsForThought December 2nd 03 09:12 PM

From: (GAUBSTER2)

Well, IMO, if they were really on the ball, they would not be advocating a
dry
food diet for a carnivore.


Why do millions of cats thrive on dry commercial diets? You've never
answered
that question and it blows you out of the water. That is mostly all that
I've
ever fed my own personal cats and they never had any health problems. But
again, you're focused only on ingredients, since apparently you aren't
sophisticated enough to wrap your brain around the whole concept of
nutrients.


LOL!!!! You have absolutely NO concept about feline nutrition. You have ZERO
credibility. It's a total waste of time to talk to you about feline nutrition
because you don't even know what it is.
________
See my cats:
http://community.webshots.com/album/56955940rWhxAe
Raw Diet Info: http://www.holisticat.com/drjletter.html
http://www.geocities.com/rawfeeders/ForCatsOnly.html
Declawing Info: http://www.wholecat.com/articles/claws.htm

GAUBSTER2 December 2nd 03 10:25 PM

From: olitter (PawsForThought)

Well, IMO, if they were really on the ball, they would not be advocating a
dry
food diet for a carnivore.


Why do millions of cats thrive on dry commercial diets? You've never
answered
that question and it blows you out of the water. That is mostly all that
I've
ever fed my own personal cats and they never had any health problems. But
again, you're focused only on ingredients, since apparently you aren't
sophisticated enough to wrap your brain around the whole concept of
nutrients.


LOL!!!! You have absolutely NO concept about feline nutrition. You have
ZERO
credibility. It's a total waste of time to talk to you about feline
nutrition
because you don't even know what it is.


Checkmate! You've lost the argument. It's interesting that I supposedly have
no concept of feline nutrition, yet none of my cats have ever been sick. Aside
from spay or neuter bills, my vet bills have been virtually non-existent.
OTOH, your cats have/had numerous problems. Why don't you answer the question?
YOU are the one that doesn't know anything about nutrition--if you did, you
wouldn't spout the dribble that you do. You are real good about making some
inane comment and then running away w/ your proverbial tail between your legs
laughing like a hyena, though!

GAUBSTER2 December 2nd 03 10:25 PM

From: olitter (PawsForThought)

Well, IMO, if they were really on the ball, they would not be advocating a
dry
food diet for a carnivore.


Why do millions of cats thrive on dry commercial diets? You've never
answered
that question and it blows you out of the water. That is mostly all that
I've
ever fed my own personal cats and they never had any health problems. But
again, you're focused only on ingredients, since apparently you aren't
sophisticated enough to wrap your brain around the whole concept of
nutrients.


LOL!!!! You have absolutely NO concept about feline nutrition. You have
ZERO
credibility. It's a total waste of time to talk to you about feline
nutrition
because you don't even know what it is.


Checkmate! You've lost the argument. It's interesting that I supposedly have
no concept of feline nutrition, yet none of my cats have ever been sick. Aside
from spay or neuter bills, my vet bills have been virtually non-existent.
OTOH, your cats have/had numerous problems. Why don't you answer the question?
YOU are the one that doesn't know anything about nutrition--if you did, you
wouldn't spout the dribble that you do. You are real good about making some
inane comment and then running away w/ your proverbial tail between your legs
laughing like a hyena, though!

GAUBSTER2 December 2nd 03 10:35 PM

From: "Jeremy Lowe"

As for only two pet food recalls, I think that is no great accomplishment.


Compared to the human food industry, you don't think that is something to take
note of??

It is not a crowning achievement for the
pet food industry to state that it has had limited recalls.


It's not? You've got to be kidding! Steve's points are very compelling. Your
point of view doesn't seem to be based in reality.

You have heard of self regulation I am sure, and if that is what the
pet food industry is doing then it could (yes I said could) be the fox
guarding the hen house.


Again, you're looking at the glass as half empty. Do you think that pet food
manufacturers want to get sued or suffer the consequences of downtime from a
recall, or the negative public perception associated w/ such an event? There
is nothing wrong w/ "self-regulation", unless you distrust everything around
you. In that case it could be (yes I said could) parnoia.

GAUBSTER2 December 2nd 03 10:35 PM

From: "Jeremy Lowe"

As for only two pet food recalls, I think that is no great accomplishment.


Compared to the human food industry, you don't think that is something to take
note of??

It is not a crowning achievement for the
pet food industry to state that it has had limited recalls.


It's not? You've got to be kidding! Steve's points are very compelling. Your
point of view doesn't seem to be based in reality.

You have heard of self regulation I am sure, and if that is what the
pet food industry is doing then it could (yes I said could) be the fox
guarding the hen house.


Again, you're looking at the glass as half empty. Do you think that pet food
manufacturers want to get sued or suffer the consequences of downtime from a
recall, or the negative public perception associated w/ such an event? There
is nothing wrong w/ "self-regulation", unless you distrust everything around
you. In that case it could be (yes I said could) parnoia.

Joe Canuck December 2nd 03 11:55 PM

Steve Crane wrote:

snip

Yikes, I should have known, another dang Quebecois like my son in law.
My youngest daughter just married a really terrific young man from
Gatineau and is living in Hull Quebec nowdays, finishing her college
at U of Ottawa - Only a few hundred miles south of you. :-)


I lived in Ottawa for 15 years, very familiar with the area. :-)

Although this place is my hometown I liked Ottawa better. Easier to get
pet food for one thing... just toddle on down to the nearest PetSmart
store and pickup whatever is needed.

The dating you are getting is a couple months behind typical US
dating, so there must be some warehousing activity in Mississaugua. I
sent an email to a friend at Hill's Canada and confirmed that
typically warehousing is about 2-3 months behind US. Part of this
apparently due to import and export regulations I have no clue about.
Apparently they feel it is appropriate to keep a 2-3 month supply on
hand in case of any import export issues that might arise.


Ah okay, that explains it then. I imagine they operate the warehouse on
the basis of sending out the oldest food in stock first.

Thank you for finding this out for me, much appreciated!

--
"Its the bugs that keep it running."
-Joe Canuck


Joe Canuck December 2nd 03 11:55 PM

Steve Crane wrote:

snip

Yikes, I should have known, another dang Quebecois like my son in law.
My youngest daughter just married a really terrific young man from
Gatineau and is living in Hull Quebec nowdays, finishing her college
at U of Ottawa - Only a few hundred miles south of you. :-)


I lived in Ottawa for 15 years, very familiar with the area. :-)

Although this place is my hometown I liked Ottawa better. Easier to get
pet food for one thing... just toddle on down to the nearest PetSmart
store and pickup whatever is needed.

The dating you are getting is a couple months behind typical US
dating, so there must be some warehousing activity in Mississaugua. I
sent an email to a friend at Hill's Canada and confirmed that
typically warehousing is about 2-3 months behind US. Part of this
apparently due to import and export regulations I have no clue about.
Apparently they feel it is appropriate to keep a 2-3 month supply on
hand in case of any import export issues that might arise.


Ah okay, that explains it then. I imagine they operate the warehouse on
the basis of sending out the oldest food in stock first.

Thank you for finding this out for me, much appreciated!

--
"Its the bugs that keep it running."
-Joe Canuck


PawsForThought December 3rd 03 01:21 PM

From: (GAUBSTER2)
Date: 12/2/2003 5:25


Checkmate! You've lost the argument.


I've lost nothing and you know it.

It's interesting that I supposedly have
no concept of feline nutrition, yet none of my cats have ever been sick.
Aside
from spay or neuter bills, my vet bills have been virtually non-existent.
OTOH, your cats have/had numerous problems. Why don't you answer the
question?


See, here is a perfect example about your comprehension problems. It was my
DECEASED CATS who did poorly and were sick while on SCIENCE DIET. My present
cats, who are fed a HOMEMADE RAW DIET that are healthy and have only been to
the vet for spay/neuter and yearly well checks. Meesha was diagnosed with
asthma BEFORE being on a homemade raw diet. Since being on the homemade raw
diet and other natural remedies, she has improved greatly. My vet is amazed
how well she is doing. We've never needed to put her on prednisone/steroids.
As I have posted before, they have a full blood panel done, at first every 6
months, but now we're thinking of going to yearly, and all numbers are well
within range. They are sleek and muscular, the most energetic cats I've ever
had, bright eyed and bushy tailed, and they have never needed a dental
cleaning, and have never had any parasites or fleas. So now what do you have to
say, asshole?

Lauren
________
See my cats:
http://community.webshots.com/album/56955940rWhxAe
Raw Diet Info: http://www.holisticat.com/drjletter.html
http://www.geocities.com/rawfeeders/ForCatsOnly.html
Declawing Info: http://www.wholecat.com/articles/claws.htm

PawsForThought December 3rd 03 01:21 PM

From: (GAUBSTER2)
Date: 12/2/2003 5:25


Checkmate! You've lost the argument.


I've lost nothing and you know it.

It's interesting that I supposedly have
no concept of feline nutrition, yet none of my cats have ever been sick.
Aside
from spay or neuter bills, my vet bills have been virtually non-existent.
OTOH, your cats have/had numerous problems. Why don't you answer the
question?


See, here is a perfect example about your comprehension problems. It was my
DECEASED CATS who did poorly and were sick while on SCIENCE DIET. My present
cats, who are fed a HOMEMADE RAW DIET that are healthy and have only been to
the vet for spay/neuter and yearly well checks. Meesha was diagnosed with
asthma BEFORE being on a homemade raw diet. Since being on the homemade raw
diet and other natural remedies, she has improved greatly. My vet is amazed
how well she is doing. We've never needed to put her on prednisone/steroids.
As I have posted before, they have a full blood panel done, at first every 6
months, but now we're thinking of going to yearly, and all numbers are well
within range. They are sleek and muscular, the most energetic cats I've ever
had, bright eyed and bushy tailed, and they have never needed a dental
cleaning, and have never had any parasites or fleas. So now what do you have to
say, asshole?

Lauren
________
See my cats:
http://community.webshots.com/album/56955940rWhxAe
Raw Diet Info: http://www.holisticat.com/drjletter.html
http://www.geocities.com/rawfeeders/ForCatsOnly.html
Declawing Info: http://www.wholecat.com/articles/claws.htm

PawsForThought December 3rd 03 01:23 PM

From: "Jeremy Lowe"


http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/q...=Retrieve&list
_uids=8914617&dopt=Abstract


http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/q...=Retrieve&list

_uids=10212800&dopt=Abstract

http://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/roc/tenth/profiles/s027bha.pdf


Thanks for posting these, Jeremy. Very interesting. Do you know if they've
done any testing at all on cats specifically for the safety of BHA/BHT?
________
See my cats: http://community.webshots.com/album/56955940rWhxAe
Raw Diet Info: http://www.holisticat.com/drjletter.html
http://www.geocities.com/rawfeeders/ForCatsOnly.html
Declawing Info: http://www.wholecat.com/articles/claws.htm


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:08 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
CatBanter.com