CatBanter

CatBanter (http://www.catbanter.com/index.php)
-   Cat health & behaviour (http://www.catbanter.com/forumdisplay.php?f=5)
-   -   Which prescription diet best for chronic constipation/lazy bowels? (http://www.catbanter.com/showthread.php?t=18738)

Devlin Tay July 14th 04 09:47 AM

Which prescription diet best for chronic constipation/lazy bowels?
 
My 1.5 year-old male tabby recently had a bad bout of constipation. Toby
did not poo for over two days and a vet check-up found a substantially
distended colon. The vet immediately put him on Propulsid (bowel stimulant)
and Duphalac (lactulose syrup) but he still refused to poo for another two
days. The vet finally administered an enema under anaesthesia, which
thankfully helped empty Toby's bowels almost immediately.

While x-rays taken before the enema showed a distended colon, it wasn't
conclusive enough for a megacolon diagnosis. The vet has now put Toby on a
mixture of Hill's Prescription Diet w/d dried and r/d canned, and reckons
that Toby will also have to be on Propulsid and Duphalac for the rest of his
life. [Toby was also recently diagnosed with struvite crystals in his
urine, which necessitated the change of diet to Hill's w/d and r/d.] While
I'm okay with Toby having to be fed a fairly expensive prescription diet for
the rest of his life, I'm not sure I am prepared to continue paying my vet
the exorbitant prices charged for the two drugs. I did some research and
discovered that Duphalac can be had for as little as AUD$12 per 500ml bottle
at pharmacies in Australia without needing a prescription - in contrast, my
vet charges me AUD$25 for a mere 25ml bottle (which lasts less than a week).
I am, of course, a little peeved at the obvious profiteering going on here.
But that's OK, since it is something I can get around by getting the
Duphalac myself. Propulsid is a more complicated matter - it is probably a
prescription drug, which means I can't buy it over-the-counter at
pharmacies, and my vet charges me AUD$65 for a wee little 25ml bottle. I
also found out that propulsid has been withdrawn from the pharmaceutical
market for humans because of allegations that it caused the deaths of
several young children. So, quite apart from cost, there is the question of
whether long term use of Propulsid could harm my little boy.

So I am at a dilemma - should I risk stopping the use of the drugs and rely
on the higher fibre combination w/d and r/d diets to keep Toby's bowels
moving? What if I leave out the Propulsid and just rely on the Duphalac to
keep Toby's stool soft/moist? Is a higher fibre diet (the Hill's w/d and
r/d) necessarily better for chronic constipation or is a low-residue diet
the way to go? Is canned pumpkin safe for a cat with a potential struvite
crystals problem?

Thanks a million to anyone who can shed some light on the above. :-)

Devlin
Perth, Australia



Devlin Tay July 14th 04 10:25 AM

By the way, Toby was fed a roughly 50%/50% diet consisting of IAMS Lamb &
Rice (dried) and Whiskas Advance (canned) with the occasional canned tuna as
a treat (about once a week) before his crystals and constipation problems
reared their ugly heads. He'll of course get no more tuna (or any other
pseudo-people foods disguised as cat foods) from now on due to the struvite
crystals problem.

Devlin
Perth, Australia



Devlin Tay July 14th 04 10:25 AM

By the way, Toby was fed a roughly 50%/50% diet consisting of IAMS Lamb &
Rice (dried) and Whiskas Advance (canned) with the occasional canned tuna as
a treat (about once a week) before his crystals and constipation problems
reared their ugly heads. He'll of course get no more tuna (or any other
pseudo-people foods disguised as cat foods) from now on due to the struvite
crystals problem.

Devlin
Perth, Australia



PawsForThought July 14th 04 01:11 PM

From: "Devlin Tay"

So I am at a dilemma - should I risk stopping the use of the drugs and rely
on the higher fibre combination w/d and r/d diets to keep Toby's bowels
moving?


If it were my cat, I would put him on a homemade diet, and also consult with a
holistic vet. Constipation sometimes occurs when the cat doesn't get enough
bulk in his diet or doesn't get enough exercise. Always make sure the
litterbox is clean so the cat doesn't get into the habit of holding it in.
Another thing you could try is adding olive oil. This can act as a tonic for
the intestinal tract and stimulate liver bile. Any excess oil will help
lubricate the fecal mass and sooth mucus membrane of the intenstine and rectum.
I would suggest 1/2 to 1 teaspoon 2 times a day, mixed with food, until he is
going regularly. It can also be given once a week for hairball prevention.

Lauren
________
See my cats:
http://community.webshots.com/album/56955940rWhxAe
Raw Diet Info: http://www.holisticat.com/drjletter.html
http://www.geocities.com/rawfeeders/ForCatsOnly.html
Declawing Info: http://www.wholecat.com/articles/claws.htm

PawsForThought July 14th 04 01:11 PM

From: "Devlin Tay"

So I am at a dilemma - should I risk stopping the use of the drugs and rely
on the higher fibre combination w/d and r/d diets to keep Toby's bowels
moving?


If it were my cat, I would put him on a homemade diet, and also consult with a
holistic vet. Constipation sometimes occurs when the cat doesn't get enough
bulk in his diet or doesn't get enough exercise. Always make sure the
litterbox is clean so the cat doesn't get into the habit of holding it in.
Another thing you could try is adding olive oil. This can act as a tonic for
the intestinal tract and stimulate liver bile. Any excess oil will help
lubricate the fecal mass and sooth mucus membrane of the intenstine and rectum.
I would suggest 1/2 to 1 teaspoon 2 times a day, mixed with food, until he is
going regularly. It can also be given once a week for hairball prevention.

Lauren
________
See my cats:
http://community.webshots.com/album/56955940rWhxAe
Raw Diet Info: http://www.holisticat.com/drjletter.html
http://www.geocities.com/rawfeeders/ForCatsOnly.html
Declawing Info: http://www.wholecat.com/articles/claws.htm

[email protected] July 14th 04 02:47 PM


The vet has now put Toby on a mixture of
Hill's Prescription Diet w/d dried and
r/d canned, and reckons that Toby will
also have to be on Propulsid and
Duphalac for the rest of his life. [Toby
was also recently diagnosed with
struvite crystals in his urine, which
necessitated the change of diet to
Hill's w/d and r/d.] While I'm okay with
Toby having to be fed a fairly expensive
prescription diet for the rest of his
life, I'm not sure I am prepared to
continue paying my vet the exorbitant
prices charged for the two drugs.


First of all, I have a real big problem with a vet that proclaims a cat
has to be on a special food/drugs for "the rest of its life" because of
*one* incident of constipation.
I also question putting the cat on the foods you described for crystals
in the urine.

The best diet for both constipation and urinary tract issues (and in
general) is one that is all canned, high quality (Iams is not) and fed
on a schedule. I have two clients that have cats that had constipation
issues that were never resolved using the prescription high fiber diets,
and one of the cats was still constipated despite getting daily doses of
mineral oil and a prescription stool softener and was in constant
misery. Completely eliminating dry food and switching the cats to a high
quality canned food fed on a 12 hour schedule resolved the constipation
in both cases and eliminated the need for stool softeners as well.

Canned is also beneficial for urinary tract issues as it greatly
increases a cats water intake, which in turn helps to keep the urine
more dilute and the bladder flushed.
In general a canned diet isgoiong to be better for your cat and there is
more and more information coming out that shows that dry foods are not
great for cats (a good website that you can check out on this subject is
http://www.catnutrition.org )

I would suggest trying this approach before deciding the cat has to have
prescription drugs and diet for the rest of its life.


Megan



"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do
nothing."

-Edmund Burke

Learn The TRUTH About Declawing
http://www.stopdeclaw.com

Zuzu's Cats Photo Album:
http://www.PictureTrail.com/zuzu22

"Concerning all acts of initiative (and creation), there is one
elementary truth the ignorance of which kills countless ideas and
splendid plans: that the moment one definitely commits oneself, then
providence moves too. A whole stream of events issues from the decision,
raising in one's favor all manner of unforeseen incidents, meetings and
material assistance, which no man could have dreamt would have come his
way."

- W.H. Murray



[email protected] July 14th 04 02:47 PM


The vet has now put Toby on a mixture of
Hill's Prescription Diet w/d dried and
r/d canned, and reckons that Toby will
also have to be on Propulsid and
Duphalac for the rest of his life. [Toby
was also recently diagnosed with
struvite crystals in his urine, which
necessitated the change of diet to
Hill's w/d and r/d.] While I'm okay with
Toby having to be fed a fairly expensive
prescription diet for the rest of his
life, I'm not sure I am prepared to
continue paying my vet the exorbitant
prices charged for the two drugs.


First of all, I have a real big problem with a vet that proclaims a cat
has to be on a special food/drugs for "the rest of its life" because of
*one* incident of constipation.
I also question putting the cat on the foods you described for crystals
in the urine.

The best diet for both constipation and urinary tract issues (and in
general) is one that is all canned, high quality (Iams is not) and fed
on a schedule. I have two clients that have cats that had constipation
issues that were never resolved using the prescription high fiber diets,
and one of the cats was still constipated despite getting daily doses of
mineral oil and a prescription stool softener and was in constant
misery. Completely eliminating dry food and switching the cats to a high
quality canned food fed on a 12 hour schedule resolved the constipation
in both cases and eliminated the need for stool softeners as well.

Canned is also beneficial for urinary tract issues as it greatly
increases a cats water intake, which in turn helps to keep the urine
more dilute and the bladder flushed.
In general a canned diet isgoiong to be better for your cat and there is
more and more information coming out that shows that dry foods are not
great for cats (a good website that you can check out on this subject is
http://www.catnutrition.org )

I would suggest trying this approach before deciding the cat has to have
prescription drugs and diet for the rest of its life.


Megan



"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do
nothing."

-Edmund Burke

Learn The TRUTH About Declawing
http://www.stopdeclaw.com

Zuzu's Cats Photo Album:
http://www.PictureTrail.com/zuzu22

"Concerning all acts of initiative (and creation), there is one
elementary truth the ignorance of which kills countless ideas and
splendid plans: that the moment one definitely commits oneself, then
providence moves too. A whole stream of events issues from the decision,
raising in one's favor all manner of unforeseen incidents, meetings and
material assistance, which no man could have dreamt would have come his
way."

- W.H. Murray



-L. : July 14th 04 05:51 PM

"Devlin Tay" wrote in message . ..
My 1.5 year-old male tabby recently had a bad bout of constipation. Toby
did not poo for over two days and a vet check-up found a substantially
distended colon. The vet immediately put him on Propulsid (bowel stimulant)
and Duphalac (lactulose syrup) but he still refused to poo for another two
days. The vet finally administered an enema under anaesthesia, which
thankfully helped empty Toby's bowels almost immediately.

While x-rays taken before the enema showed a distended colon, it wasn't
conclusive enough for a megacolon diagnosis. The vet has now put Toby on a
mixture of Hill's Prescription Diet w/d dried and r/d canned, and reckons
that Toby will also have to be on Propulsid and Duphalac for the rest of his
life. [Toby was also recently diagnosed with struvite crystals in his
urine, which necessitated the change of diet to Hill's w/d and r/d.] While
I'm okay with Toby having to be fed a fairly expensive prescription diet for
the rest of his life, I'm not sure I am prepared to continue paying my vet
the exorbitant prices charged for the two drugs. I did some research and
discovered that Duphalac can be had for as little as AUD$12 per 500ml bottle
at pharmacies in Australia without needing a prescription - in contrast, my
vet charges me AUD$25 for a mere 25ml bottle (which lasts less than a week).
I am, of course, a little peeved at the obvious profiteering going on here.
But that's OK, since it is something I can get around by getting the
Duphalac myself. Propulsid is a more complicated matter - it is probably a
prescription drug, which means I can't buy it over-the-counter at
pharmacies, and my vet charges me AUD$65 for a wee little 25ml bottle. I
also found out that propulsid has been withdrawn from the pharmaceutical
market for humans because of allegations that it caused the deaths of
several young children. So, quite apart from cost, there is the question of
whether long term use of Propulsid could harm my little boy.

So I am at a dilemma - should I risk stopping the use of the drugs and rely
on the higher fibre combination w/d and r/d diets to keep Toby's bowels
moving? What if I leave out the Propulsid and just rely on the Duphalac to
keep Toby's stool soft/moist? Is a higher fibre diet (the Hill's w/d and
r/d) necessarily better for chronic constipation or is a low-residue diet
the way to go? Is canned pumpkin safe for a cat with a potential struvite
crystals problem?


I have seen r/d and w/d do nothing except keep a cat coming back to
the vet for enemas. I would trash the Hills, put the cat on a
hairball maintenence dry diet (which is higer in fiber and Mega 3
fatty acids) with pumpkin (if he will eat it) and also give plenty of
canned food that is high in protein - such as Purina DM or a canned
kitten diet. Protein is better utilized and lower-residue in nature.
I would keep him on the drugs until he seems completely regulated.

Make sure is he groomed frequently, get enough exercise and plenty of
water. Massage can also help.

best of luck to you,

-L.

-L. : July 14th 04 05:51 PM

"Devlin Tay" wrote in message . ..
My 1.5 year-old male tabby recently had a bad bout of constipation. Toby
did not poo for over two days and a vet check-up found a substantially
distended colon. The vet immediately put him on Propulsid (bowel stimulant)
and Duphalac (lactulose syrup) but he still refused to poo for another two
days. The vet finally administered an enema under anaesthesia, which
thankfully helped empty Toby's bowels almost immediately.

While x-rays taken before the enema showed a distended colon, it wasn't
conclusive enough for a megacolon diagnosis. The vet has now put Toby on a
mixture of Hill's Prescription Diet w/d dried and r/d canned, and reckons
that Toby will also have to be on Propulsid and Duphalac for the rest of his
life. [Toby was also recently diagnosed with struvite crystals in his
urine, which necessitated the change of diet to Hill's w/d and r/d.] While
I'm okay with Toby having to be fed a fairly expensive prescription diet for
the rest of his life, I'm not sure I am prepared to continue paying my vet
the exorbitant prices charged for the two drugs. I did some research and
discovered that Duphalac can be had for as little as AUD$12 per 500ml bottle
at pharmacies in Australia without needing a prescription - in contrast, my
vet charges me AUD$25 for a mere 25ml bottle (which lasts less than a week).
I am, of course, a little peeved at the obvious profiteering going on here.
But that's OK, since it is something I can get around by getting the
Duphalac myself. Propulsid is a more complicated matter - it is probably a
prescription drug, which means I can't buy it over-the-counter at
pharmacies, and my vet charges me AUD$65 for a wee little 25ml bottle. I
also found out that propulsid has been withdrawn from the pharmaceutical
market for humans because of allegations that it caused the deaths of
several young children. So, quite apart from cost, there is the question of
whether long term use of Propulsid could harm my little boy.

So I am at a dilemma - should I risk stopping the use of the drugs and rely
on the higher fibre combination w/d and r/d diets to keep Toby's bowels
moving? What if I leave out the Propulsid and just rely on the Duphalac to
keep Toby's stool soft/moist? Is a higher fibre diet (the Hill's w/d and
r/d) necessarily better for chronic constipation or is a low-residue diet
the way to go? Is canned pumpkin safe for a cat with a potential struvite
crystals problem?


I have seen r/d and w/d do nothing except keep a cat coming back to
the vet for enemas. I would trash the Hills, put the cat on a
hairball maintenence dry diet (which is higer in fiber and Mega 3
fatty acids) with pumpkin (if he will eat it) and also give plenty of
canned food that is high in protein - such as Purina DM or a canned
kitten diet. Protein is better utilized and lower-residue in nature.
I would keep him on the drugs until he seems completely regulated.

Make sure is he groomed frequently, get enough exercise and plenty of
water. Massage can also help.

best of luck to you,

-L.

[email protected] July 14th 04 06:35 PM

Lyn wrote:

I would trash the Hills, put the cat on a
hairball maintenence dry diet (which is
higer in fiber and Mega 3 fatty acids) with
pumpkin (if he will eat it) and also give
plenty of canned food that is high in
protein - such as Purina DM or a canned
kitten diet. Protein is better utilized and
lower-residue in nature.


This is contradictory. A dry, high fiber diet will contribute to stool
size and is full of grains which a cat cannot utilize and can be
considered "residue" that just passes through. Feeding this and a low
residue diet would defeat the purpose of the low-residue food. Since
this cat has already had a blockage once, I wouldn't recommend foods
that are going to increase his stool size. Feeding a canned food means
that the cat will digest and utilize more of the food and stool size
will be smaller, which is certainly preferable if the cat is still
constipated after the diet change. At least he'd be able to pass them
and canned pumpkin could be added to the mix to help soften them, but my
guess based on experience is that a grain free strictly canned food diet
will take care of the problem.

Megan



"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do
nothing."

-Edmund Burke

Learn The TRUTH About Declawing
http://www.stopdeclaw.com

Zuzu's Cats Photo Album:
http://www.PictureTrail.com/zuzu22

"Concerning all acts of initiative (and creation), there is one
elementary truth the ignorance of which kills countless ideas and
splendid plans: that the moment one definitely commits oneself, then
providence moves too. A whole stream of events issues from the decision,
raising in one's favor all manner of unforeseen incidents, meetings and
material assistance, which no man could have dreamt would have come his
way."

- W.H. Murray



[email protected] July 14th 04 06:35 PM

Lyn wrote:

I would trash the Hills, put the cat on a
hairball maintenence dry diet (which is
higer in fiber and Mega 3 fatty acids) with
pumpkin (if he will eat it) and also give
plenty of canned food that is high in
protein - such as Purina DM or a canned
kitten diet. Protein is better utilized and
lower-residue in nature.


This is contradictory. A dry, high fiber diet will contribute to stool
size and is full of grains which a cat cannot utilize and can be
considered "residue" that just passes through. Feeding this and a low
residue diet would defeat the purpose of the low-residue food. Since
this cat has already had a blockage once, I wouldn't recommend foods
that are going to increase his stool size. Feeding a canned food means
that the cat will digest and utilize more of the food and stool size
will be smaller, which is certainly preferable if the cat is still
constipated after the diet change. At least he'd be able to pass them
and canned pumpkin could be added to the mix to help soften them, but my
guess based on experience is that a grain free strictly canned food diet
will take care of the problem.

Megan



"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do
nothing."

-Edmund Burke

Learn The TRUTH About Declawing
http://www.stopdeclaw.com

Zuzu's Cats Photo Album:
http://www.PictureTrail.com/zuzu22

"Concerning all acts of initiative (and creation), there is one
elementary truth the ignorance of which kills countless ideas and
splendid plans: that the moment one definitely commits oneself, then
providence moves too. A whole stream of events issues from the decision,
raising in one's favor all manner of unforeseen incidents, meetings and
material assistance, which no man could have dreamt would have come his
way."

- W.H. Murray



-L. : July 15th 04 04:59 AM

wrote in message ...
Lyn wrote:

I would trash the Hills, put the cat on a
hairball maintenence dry diet (which is
higer in fiber and Mega 3 fatty acids) with
pumpkin (if he will eat it) and also give
plenty of canned food that is high in
protein - such as Purina DM or a canned
kitten diet. Protein is better utilized and
lower-residue in nature.


This is contradictory. A dry, high fiber diet will contribute to stool
size and is full of grains which a cat cannot utilize and can be
considered "residue" that just passes through. Feeding this and a low
residue diet would defeat the purpose of the low-residue food. Since
this cat has already had a blockage once, I wouldn't recommend foods
that are going to increase his stool size. Feeding a canned food means
that the cat will digest and utilize more of the food and stool size
will be smaller, which is certainly preferable if the cat is still
constipated after the diet change. At least he'd be able to pass them
and canned pumpkin could be added to the mix to help soften them, but my
guess based on experience is that a grain free strictly canned food diet
will take care of the problem.

Megan


I just posted what worked for me. A combination of the two different
types of food, fed pretty much at will, allowed the cat to eat what he
wanted/needed to pass the stool/keep the digestion working. This
combo got him past his hairball blockage and chronic constipation
problem and has him back to being regular again. I think the fiber in
combo helped push everything along. If I had listened to the vet, the
cat would be dead.

-L.

-L. : July 15th 04 04:59 AM

wrote in message ...
Lyn wrote:

I would trash the Hills, put the cat on a
hairball maintenence dry diet (which is
higer in fiber and Mega 3 fatty acids) with
pumpkin (if he will eat it) and also give
plenty of canned food that is high in
protein - such as Purina DM or a canned
kitten diet. Protein is better utilized and
lower-residue in nature.


This is contradictory. A dry, high fiber diet will contribute to stool
size and is full of grains which a cat cannot utilize and can be
considered "residue" that just passes through. Feeding this and a low
residue diet would defeat the purpose of the low-residue food. Since
this cat has already had a blockage once, I wouldn't recommend foods
that are going to increase his stool size. Feeding a canned food means
that the cat will digest and utilize more of the food and stool size
will be smaller, which is certainly preferable if the cat is still
constipated after the diet change. At least he'd be able to pass them
and canned pumpkin could be added to the mix to help soften them, but my
guess based on experience is that a grain free strictly canned food diet
will take care of the problem.

Megan


I just posted what worked for me. A combination of the two different
types of food, fed pretty much at will, allowed the cat to eat what he
wanted/needed to pass the stool/keep the digestion working. This
combo got him past his hairball blockage and chronic constipation
problem and has him back to being regular again. I think the fiber in
combo helped push everything along. If I had listened to the vet, the
cat would be dead.

-L.

Steve G July 16th 04 01:16 AM

wrote in message ...
(...)
This is contradictory. A dry, high fiber diet will contribute to stool
size and is full of grains which a cat cannot utilize and can be
considered "residue" that just passes through.


Picking up on one point: The above isn't so - cats certainly can
utilize grains / carbohydrates. For example, Funaba et al. (2001)
found that the digestibility of corn gluten meal and fish meal were
not significantly different. In 2002 the same group found that meat
meal was significantly more digestible than corn gluten meal. However,
the corn gluten meal certainly was not 'residue' and the cats could
(and did) gain energy from it.

Steve.

Steve G July 16th 04 01:16 AM

wrote in message ...
(...)
This is contradictory. A dry, high fiber diet will contribute to stool
size and is full of grains which a cat cannot utilize and can be
considered "residue" that just passes through.


Picking up on one point: The above isn't so - cats certainly can
utilize grains / carbohydrates. For example, Funaba et al. (2001)
found that the digestibility of corn gluten meal and fish meal were
not significantly different. In 2002 the same group found that meat
meal was significantly more digestible than corn gluten meal. However,
the corn gluten meal certainly was not 'residue' and the cats could
(and did) gain energy from it.

Steve.

[email protected] July 16th 04 02:05 AM

Funaba et al. (2001) found that the
digestibility of corn gluten meal and fish
meal were not significantly different. In
2002 the same group found that meat
meal was significantly more digestible
than corn gluten meal. However, the corn
gluten meal certainly was not 'residue'
and the cats could (and did) gain energy
from it.


If I had said corn gluten meal was at issue you might have a slightly
valid point. You don't and have conveniently chosen to ignore the fact
that "hairball remedy" foods contain more than just corn gluten meal.
Many contain any number of things such as ground corn, rice, soybean
mill run and other such non-essentials that aren't going to be fully
digested. The bottom line here is that if we feed cats food that is as
close to what is *appropriate for the species* (corn, rice, etc. is
not), instead of forcing them to consume foods that are completely
contrary to what a *strict carnivore* should be eating, a lot of the
problems we see today like constipation, diabetes, kidney failure, IBD,
UTI's, etc. would be few. Will you now be making justifications for why
a cow should eat meat?

Megan.



"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do
nothing."

-Edmund Burke

Learn The TRUTH About Declawing
http://www.stopdeclaw.com

Zuzu's Cats Photo Album:
http://www.PictureTrail.com/zuzu22

"Concerning all acts of initiative (and creation), there is one
elementary truth the ignorance of which kills countless ideas and
splendid plans: that the moment one definitely commits oneself, then
providence moves too. A whole stream of events issues from the decision,
raising in one's favor all manner of unforeseen incidents, meetings and
material assistance, which no man could have dreamt would have come his
way."

- W.H. Murray



[email protected] July 16th 04 02:05 AM

Funaba et al. (2001) found that the
digestibility of corn gluten meal and fish
meal were not significantly different. In
2002 the same group found that meat
meal was significantly more digestible
than corn gluten meal. However, the corn
gluten meal certainly was not 'residue'
and the cats could (and did) gain energy
from it.


If I had said corn gluten meal was at issue you might have a slightly
valid point. You don't and have conveniently chosen to ignore the fact
that "hairball remedy" foods contain more than just corn gluten meal.
Many contain any number of things such as ground corn, rice, soybean
mill run and other such non-essentials that aren't going to be fully
digested. The bottom line here is that if we feed cats food that is as
close to what is *appropriate for the species* (corn, rice, etc. is
not), instead of forcing them to consume foods that are completely
contrary to what a *strict carnivore* should be eating, a lot of the
problems we see today like constipation, diabetes, kidney failure, IBD,
UTI's, etc. would be few. Will you now be making justifications for why
a cow should eat meat?

Megan.



"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do
nothing."

-Edmund Burke

Learn The TRUTH About Declawing
http://www.stopdeclaw.com

Zuzu's Cats Photo Album:
http://www.PictureTrail.com/zuzu22

"Concerning all acts of initiative (and creation), there is one
elementary truth the ignorance of which kills countless ideas and
splendid plans: that the moment one definitely commits oneself, then
providence moves too. A whole stream of events issues from the decision,
raising in one's favor all manner of unforeseen incidents, meetings and
material assistance, which no man could have dreamt would have come his
way."

- W.H. Murray



GAUBSTER2 July 16th 04 03:55 PM

From:

Duphalac for the rest of his life. [Toby
was also recently diagnosed with
struvite crystals in his urine, which
necessitated the change of diet to
Hill's w/d and r/d.]


I also question putting the cat on the foods you described for crystals
in the urine.


Feline w/d and r/d from Hill's are formulated with a pH range of 6.2-6.4 which
will help manage crystals. So, you are wrong on that count, Megan.

First of all, I have a real big problem with a vet that proclaims a cat
has to be on a special food/drugs for "the rest of its life" because of
*one* incident of constipation.


Have you seen the test results yourself? How can you diagnose over the
internet? I would trust that vet before trusting some anonymous layperson on
usenet.

The best diet for both constipation and urinary tract issues (and in
general) is one that is all canned, high quality (Iams is not) and fed
on a schedule.


"High quality" is subjective for most people. Higher fiber foods can indeed
help with constipation.

I have two clients that have cats that had constipation
issues that were never resolved using the prescription high fiber diets,
and one of the cats was still constipated despite getting daily doses of
mineral oil and a prescription stool softener and was in constant
misery.


2 clients are not indicative of the entire cat population and are not a good
measure of whether or not something "works". You should know that.

GAUBSTER2 July 16th 04 03:55 PM

From:

Duphalac for the rest of his life. [Toby
was also recently diagnosed with
struvite crystals in his urine, which
necessitated the change of diet to
Hill's w/d and r/d.]


I also question putting the cat on the foods you described for crystals
in the urine.


Feline w/d and r/d from Hill's are formulated with a pH range of 6.2-6.4 which
will help manage crystals. So, you are wrong on that count, Megan.

First of all, I have a real big problem with a vet that proclaims a cat
has to be on a special food/drugs for "the rest of its life" because of
*one* incident of constipation.


Have you seen the test results yourself? How can you diagnose over the
internet? I would trust that vet before trusting some anonymous layperson on
usenet.

The best diet for both constipation and urinary tract issues (and in
general) is one that is all canned, high quality (Iams is not) and fed
on a schedule.


"High quality" is subjective for most people. Higher fiber foods can indeed
help with constipation.

I have two clients that have cats that had constipation
issues that were never resolved using the prescription high fiber diets,
and one of the cats was still constipated despite getting daily doses of
mineral oil and a prescription stool softener and was in constant
misery.


2 clients are not indicative of the entire cat population and are not a good
measure of whether or not something "works". You should know that.

[email protected] July 16th 04 04:42 PM

Gaubster wrote:

Feline w/d and r/d from Hill's are
formulated with a pH range of 6.2-6.4
which will help manage crystals. So, you
are wrong on that count, Megan.


No I'm not. I never said it was wrong to feed that. I said I "questioned
it" which is entirely different. Apparently it didn't occur to you that
managing crystals and dissolving them are two different things.


First of all, I have a real big problem with
a vet that proclaims a cat has to be on a
special food/drugs for "the rest of its life"
because of *one* incident of constipation.


Have you seen the test results yourself?
How can you diagnose over the internet?

I didn't make diagnosis. Again you are too ignorant to comprehend basic
language. I questioned the proclamation that the cat would have this
condition for life based solely on *one* incident, which is completely
valid.
Just because you blindly follow whatever a vet or Hills tells you
without doing any research or using common sense doesn't mean others
should.

snip the rest of Gaubsters typical attempt to start an argument over
food

Megan



"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do
nothing."

-Edmund Burke

Learn The TRUTH About Declawing
http://www.stopdeclaw.com

Zuzu's Cats Photo Album:
http://www.PictureTrail.com/zuzu22

"Concerning all acts of initiative (and creation), there is one
elementary truth the ignorance of which kills countless ideas and
splendid plans: that the moment one definitely commits oneself, then
providence moves too. A whole stream of events issues from the decision,
raising in one's favor all manner of unforeseen incidents, meetings and
material assistance, which no man could have dreamt would have come his
way."

- W.H. Murray



[email protected] July 16th 04 04:42 PM

Gaubster wrote:

Feline w/d and r/d from Hill's are
formulated with a pH range of 6.2-6.4
which will help manage crystals. So, you
are wrong on that count, Megan.


No I'm not. I never said it was wrong to feed that. I said I "questioned
it" which is entirely different. Apparently it didn't occur to you that
managing crystals and dissolving them are two different things.


First of all, I have a real big problem with
a vet that proclaims a cat has to be on a
special food/drugs for "the rest of its life"
because of *one* incident of constipation.


Have you seen the test results yourself?
How can you diagnose over the internet?

I didn't make diagnosis. Again you are too ignorant to comprehend basic
language. I questioned the proclamation that the cat would have this
condition for life based solely on *one* incident, which is completely
valid.
Just because you blindly follow whatever a vet or Hills tells you
without doing any research or using common sense doesn't mean others
should.

snip the rest of Gaubsters typical attempt to start an argument over
food

Megan



"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do
nothing."

-Edmund Burke

Learn The TRUTH About Declawing
http://www.stopdeclaw.com

Zuzu's Cats Photo Album:
http://www.PictureTrail.com/zuzu22

"Concerning all acts of initiative (and creation), there is one
elementary truth the ignorance of which kills countless ideas and
splendid plans: that the moment one definitely commits oneself, then
providence moves too. A whole stream of events issues from the decision,
raising in one's favor all manner of unforeseen incidents, meetings and
material assistance, which no man could have dreamt would have come his
way."

- W.H. Murray



Steve G July 16th 04 05:38 PM

wrote in message ...
Funaba et al. (2001) found that the
digestibility of corn gluten meal and fish
meal were not significantly different. (...)


If I had said corn gluten meal was at issue you might have a slightly
valid point. You don't and have conveniently chosen to ignore the fact
that "hairball remedy" foods contain more than just corn gluten meal.


I see. So, CGM doesn't count even thought it's extracted from corn?
Not sure what your logic is on this one. And *all* cat foods contain
more vegetable or vegetable-derived matter than just CGM.

Anyway: How about polenta - see Riond et al. (2003)? According to
these chaps, cats can digest polenta.

Or, the appropriately-named LaFlamme & Long (2004) [Vet Ther 5, 43-51]
who speak of 'a highly digestible, moderate-carbohydrate diet', and
'highly digestible, high-protein, low-carbohydrate diet'. The research
did come out of Purina, so those with tinfoil wrapping can summarily
dismiss the paper if they so wish.

Another paper by Funaba et al. (2004) [Am J Vet Res 65: 138-142]
suggests that carbs are not optimal, but because they may facilitate
urolith formation, not because the carbs are 'indigestible'.

Caveat with the above 3 - I've only read the abstract in each case.

Many contain any number of things such as ground corn, rice, soybean
mill run and other such non-essentials that aren't going to be fully
digested. The bottom line here is that if we feed cats food that is as
close to what is *appropriate for the species* (corn, rice, etc. is
not), instead of forcing them to consume foods that are completely
contrary to what a *strict carnivore* should be eating


If cats could indeed digest carbs poorly or not at all, I think that
we wouldn't have quite as many obese (indoor) cats as we do, given the
popularity of dry foods.

Not sure that cats eat sweet potatoes in their natural environment
(Wellness) either, or perhaps they have hidden digging talents. And
peas (Natural Life)! Yes, I always have to shoo the cats away from the
pea-patch, always swiping the pods, the buggers. How about dried kelp
(Newman's Own), doubtless caught be those wily aquacats. Or guar gum
(basically everything). Brown rice, cranberry meal (Felidae). Repeat
to fade.

Not sure that a cat could bring down a cow or sheep either, but who's
to say what ambitious felines are out there...

, a lot of the
problems we see today like constipation, diabetes, kidney failure, IBD,
UTI's, etc. would be few.


Big statements - but alas, no big evidence to back 'em up.

Now, I do actually agree with you that feeding a species appropriate
diet is an appropriate [sic] thing to do, but if you try to justify
this by assigning all manner of ills to carbs - well, there just ain't
the evidence AFAICT. Do you have any cites?

Will you now be making justifications for why
a cow should eat meat?


For better or worse, many animals raised for human consumption are
indeed forced to eat a species inappropriate diet.

Steve.

Steve G July 16th 04 05:38 PM

wrote in message ...
Funaba et al. (2001) found that the
digestibility of corn gluten meal and fish
meal were not significantly different. (...)


If I had said corn gluten meal was at issue you might have a slightly
valid point. You don't and have conveniently chosen to ignore the fact
that "hairball remedy" foods contain more than just corn gluten meal.


I see. So, CGM doesn't count even thought it's extracted from corn?
Not sure what your logic is on this one. And *all* cat foods contain
more vegetable or vegetable-derived matter than just CGM.

Anyway: How about polenta - see Riond et al. (2003)? According to
these chaps, cats can digest polenta.

Or, the appropriately-named LaFlamme & Long (2004) [Vet Ther 5, 43-51]
who speak of 'a highly digestible, moderate-carbohydrate diet', and
'highly digestible, high-protein, low-carbohydrate diet'. The research
did come out of Purina, so those with tinfoil wrapping can summarily
dismiss the paper if they so wish.

Another paper by Funaba et al. (2004) [Am J Vet Res 65: 138-142]
suggests that carbs are not optimal, but because they may facilitate
urolith formation, not because the carbs are 'indigestible'.

Caveat with the above 3 - I've only read the abstract in each case.

Many contain any number of things such as ground corn, rice, soybean
mill run and other such non-essentials that aren't going to be fully
digested. The bottom line here is that if we feed cats food that is as
close to what is *appropriate for the species* (corn, rice, etc. is
not), instead of forcing them to consume foods that are completely
contrary to what a *strict carnivore* should be eating


If cats could indeed digest carbs poorly or not at all, I think that
we wouldn't have quite as many obese (indoor) cats as we do, given the
popularity of dry foods.

Not sure that cats eat sweet potatoes in their natural environment
(Wellness) either, or perhaps they have hidden digging talents. And
peas (Natural Life)! Yes, I always have to shoo the cats away from the
pea-patch, always swiping the pods, the buggers. How about dried kelp
(Newman's Own), doubtless caught be those wily aquacats. Or guar gum
(basically everything). Brown rice, cranberry meal (Felidae). Repeat
to fade.

Not sure that a cat could bring down a cow or sheep either, but who's
to say what ambitious felines are out there...

, a lot of the
problems we see today like constipation, diabetes, kidney failure, IBD,
UTI's, etc. would be few.


Big statements - but alas, no big evidence to back 'em up.

Now, I do actually agree with you that feeding a species appropriate
diet is an appropriate [sic] thing to do, but if you try to justify
this by assigning all manner of ills to carbs - well, there just ain't
the evidence AFAICT. Do you have any cites?

Will you now be making justifications for why
a cow should eat meat?


For better or worse, many animals raised for human consumption are
indeed forced to eat a species inappropriate diet.

Steve.

Devlin Tay July 17th 04 05:18 AM

Thanks to everyone who gave their input. It was good to get such a diverse
(and sometimes contradictory) range of views. Even the vets (and there were
several of them from the same vet practice who examined Toby) couldn't all
agree upon what the problem(s) might be, so I guess I shouldn't feel guilty
about being all confused.

Toby first got ill about 2 months ago - I noticed he had been going to the
litter tray every few minutes - I carted him off to the vet immediately,
where the first vet took a urine sample and tested it for crystals and/or
bacteria. That first test came back positive for bacteria but negative for
crystals. Toby was put on antibiotics, but no change of diet was
recommended (he was being fed IAMS dried and Whiskas Advance wet). He had
an anti-inflammation shot as well, and the frequent litter tray visits
stopped - he got back to his normal routine of 2/3 times of weeing a day.

A few weeks later, when Toby went to the clinic for a follow-up urine test
after completing his course of antibiotics, a second vet discovered that
Toby was badly constipated and had a distended colon. (Toby had always
poo'd every other day - I simply accepted that as his normal routine, I
never suspected he might be constipated. He never showed any signs of
straining or pain when he poo'd before.) After Toby failed to poo for 4
days in a row (despite being treated with both lactulose and cisapride), a
third and fourth vet (from the same clinic) recommended an enema under
anaesthesia - this was duly administered after an x-ray was taken. The last
two vets said the x-ray was inconclusive for a megacolon diagnosis, although
Toby's colon was distended.

Meanwhile, the second urine test came back - Toby had struvite crystals AND
bacteria! Vet no. 2 decided that the bacteria could be lab contamination,
so no additional antibiotics were prescribed. So the decision was made to
put Toby on the Hill's dried w/d and wet r/d combination (both had higher
fibre, are formulated to keep urine urine pH at 6.2 to 6.4, and the wet r/d
would ensure Toby has sufficient fluid intake).

Fast-forward to two weeks later - a third urine test this week showed Toby's
urine is free from either bacteria or struvite crystals. Phew! However,
vet no. 2 felt that it would be wise to continue with the Hill's diet as
well as the lactulose and cisapride treatment for the foreseeable future as
Toby's colon continues to be distended (although he now poos regularly once
every 1 to 1.5 days).

Three different urine tests yielding 3 different results, on top of a
possible idiopathic megacolon diagnosis - the vets don't have a clue why
Toby's constipation developed nor why it progressed to the almost megacolon
stage. It's all pretty much guess-work at this stage - keeping my fingers
crossed that Toby's bowel movements will go back to normal eventually and he
can be safely taken off the cisapride. (Cisapride is expensive and has been
suspected of causing a few human deaths and withdrawn from the human market
so it is not easy to get except thru vets, but lactulose is just a synthetic
sugar and unlikely to cause any long term harm, plus it is much cheaper and
easier to obtain.)

It has been a very stressful couple of months for this daddy!

Devlin
Perth, Australia



Devlin Tay July 17th 04 05:18 AM

Thanks to everyone who gave their input. It was good to get such a diverse
(and sometimes contradictory) range of views. Even the vets (and there were
several of them from the same vet practice who examined Toby) couldn't all
agree upon what the problem(s) might be, so I guess I shouldn't feel guilty
about being all confused.

Toby first got ill about 2 months ago - I noticed he had been going to the
litter tray every few minutes - I carted him off to the vet immediately,
where the first vet took a urine sample and tested it for crystals and/or
bacteria. That first test came back positive for bacteria but negative for
crystals. Toby was put on antibiotics, but no change of diet was
recommended (he was being fed IAMS dried and Whiskas Advance wet). He had
an anti-inflammation shot as well, and the frequent litter tray visits
stopped - he got back to his normal routine of 2/3 times of weeing a day.

A few weeks later, when Toby went to the clinic for a follow-up urine test
after completing his course of antibiotics, a second vet discovered that
Toby was badly constipated and had a distended colon. (Toby had always
poo'd every other day - I simply accepted that as his normal routine, I
never suspected he might be constipated. He never showed any signs of
straining or pain when he poo'd before.) After Toby failed to poo for 4
days in a row (despite being treated with both lactulose and cisapride), a
third and fourth vet (from the same clinic) recommended an enema under
anaesthesia - this was duly administered after an x-ray was taken. The last
two vets said the x-ray was inconclusive for a megacolon diagnosis, although
Toby's colon was distended.

Meanwhile, the second urine test came back - Toby had struvite crystals AND
bacteria! Vet no. 2 decided that the bacteria could be lab contamination,
so no additional antibiotics were prescribed. So the decision was made to
put Toby on the Hill's dried w/d and wet r/d combination (both had higher
fibre, are formulated to keep urine urine pH at 6.2 to 6.4, and the wet r/d
would ensure Toby has sufficient fluid intake).

Fast-forward to two weeks later - a third urine test this week showed Toby's
urine is free from either bacteria or struvite crystals. Phew! However,
vet no. 2 felt that it would be wise to continue with the Hill's diet as
well as the lactulose and cisapride treatment for the foreseeable future as
Toby's colon continues to be distended (although he now poos regularly once
every 1 to 1.5 days).

Three different urine tests yielding 3 different results, on top of a
possible idiopathic megacolon diagnosis - the vets don't have a clue why
Toby's constipation developed nor why it progressed to the almost megacolon
stage. It's all pretty much guess-work at this stage - keeping my fingers
crossed that Toby's bowel movements will go back to normal eventually and he
can be safely taken off the cisapride. (Cisapride is expensive and has been
suspected of causing a few human deaths and withdrawn from the human market
so it is not easy to get except thru vets, but lactulose is just a synthetic
sugar and unlikely to cause any long term harm, plus it is much cheaper and
easier to obtain.)

It has been a very stressful couple of months for this daddy!

Devlin
Perth, Australia



PawsForThought July 17th 04 11:39 PM

From: "Devlin Tay"

Toby's colon continues to be distended (although he now poos regularly once
every 1 to 1.5 days).


Three different urine tests yielding 3 different results, on top of a
possible idiopathic megacolon diagnosis


There's a great group you could join for cats with IBD and other bowel
problems:

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/FelineIBD
________
See my cats: http://community.webshots.com/album/56955940rWhxAe
Raw Diet Info: http://www.holisticat.com/drjletter.html
http://www.geocities.com/rawfeeders/ForCatsOnly.html
Declawing Info: http://www.wholecatjournal.com/articles/claws.htm

PawsForThought July 17th 04 11:39 PM

From: "Devlin Tay"

Toby's colon continues to be distended (although he now poos regularly once
every 1 to 1.5 days).


Three different urine tests yielding 3 different results, on top of a
possible idiopathic megacolon diagnosis


There's a great group you could join for cats with IBD and other bowel
problems:

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/FelineIBD
________
See my cats: http://community.webshots.com/album/56955940rWhxAe
Raw Diet Info: http://www.holisticat.com/drjletter.html
http://www.geocities.com/rawfeeders/ForCatsOnly.html
Declawing Info: http://www.wholecatjournal.com/articles/claws.htm

GAUBSTER2 July 18th 04 05:12 AM

From:

Apparently it didn't occur to you that
managing crystals and dissolving them are two different things.


Of course it did. But you're too busy putting words into people's mouths to
stop and think, now aren't you?

Let's see what the OP found out:

------------
Meanwhile, the second urine test came back - Toby had struvite crystals AND
bacteria! Vet no. 2 decided that the bacteria could be lab contamination,
so no additional antibiotics were prescribed. So the decision was made to
put Toby on the Hill's dried w/d and wet r/d combination (both had higher
fibre, are formulated to keep urine urine pH at 6.2 to 6.4, and the wet r/d
would ensure Toby has sufficient fluid intake).

Fast-forward to two weeks later - a third urine test this week showed Toby's
urine is free from either bacteria or struvite crystals. Phew! However,
vet no. 2 felt that it would be wise to continue with the Hill's diet as
well as the lactulose and cisapride treatment for the foreseeable future as
Toby's colon continues to be distended (although he now poos regularly once
every 1 to 1.5 days).
-----------------

Looks like they resolved that problem with the help of the Hill's diets. Once
again, Megan your advice turns out to be off the mark.

First of all, I have a real big problem with
a vet that proclaims a cat has to be on a
special food/drugs for "the rest of its life"
because of *one* incident of constipation.



Have you seen the test results yourself?
How can you diagnose over the internet?


Just because you blindly follow whatever a vet or Hills tells you
without doing any research or using common sense doesn't mean others
should.


....and what research did you do on THIS particular case?? None, because you
didn't examine the animal personally, nor did you have access to the cat's
records. Pull your head out, Megan.

snip the rest of Gaubsters typical attempt to start an argument over
food


Again, you're putting words into people's mouths. I'm simply questioning your
arrogance.

GAUBSTER2 July 18th 04 05:12 AM

From:

Apparently it didn't occur to you that
managing crystals and dissolving them are two different things.


Of course it did. But you're too busy putting words into people's mouths to
stop and think, now aren't you?

Let's see what the OP found out:

------------
Meanwhile, the second urine test came back - Toby had struvite crystals AND
bacteria! Vet no. 2 decided that the bacteria could be lab contamination,
so no additional antibiotics were prescribed. So the decision was made to
put Toby on the Hill's dried w/d and wet r/d combination (both had higher
fibre, are formulated to keep urine urine pH at 6.2 to 6.4, and the wet r/d
would ensure Toby has sufficient fluid intake).

Fast-forward to two weeks later - a third urine test this week showed Toby's
urine is free from either bacteria or struvite crystals. Phew! However,
vet no. 2 felt that it would be wise to continue with the Hill's diet as
well as the lactulose and cisapride treatment for the foreseeable future as
Toby's colon continues to be distended (although he now poos regularly once
every 1 to 1.5 days).
-----------------

Looks like they resolved that problem with the help of the Hill's diets. Once
again, Megan your advice turns out to be off the mark.

First of all, I have a real big problem with
a vet that proclaims a cat has to be on a
special food/drugs for "the rest of its life"
because of *one* incident of constipation.



Have you seen the test results yourself?
How can you diagnose over the internet?


Just because you blindly follow whatever a vet or Hills tells you
without doing any research or using common sense doesn't mean others
should.


....and what research did you do on THIS particular case?? None, because you
didn't examine the animal personally, nor did you have access to the cat's
records. Pull your head out, Megan.

snip the rest of Gaubsters typical attempt to start an argument over
food


Again, you're putting words into people's mouths. I'm simply questioning your
arrogance.

GAUBSTER2 July 18th 04 05:14 AM

From: (Steve G)

Well, Steve, I have to agree with the points you made debating Megan. She
clearly is more interested in ingredients vs. nutrients and is a carbophobic:



Funaba et al. (2001) found that the
digestibility of corn gluten meal and fish
meal were not significantly different. (...)


If I had said corn gluten meal was at issue you might have a slightly
valid point. You don't and have conveniently chosen to ignore the fact
that "hairball remedy" foods contain more than just corn gluten meal.


I see. So, CGM doesn't count even thought it's extracted from corn?
Not sure what your logic is on this one. And *all* cat foods contain
more vegetable or vegetable-derived matter than just CGM.


Another paper by Funaba et al. (2004) [Am J Vet Res 65: 138-142]
suggests that carbs are not optimal, but because they may facilitate
urolith formation, not because the carbs are 'indigestible'.


If cats could indeed digest carbs poorly or not at all, I think that
we wouldn't have quite as many obese (indoor) cats as we do, given the
popularity of dry foods.


Uh oh, you just used logic on Megan!!

Not sure that cats eat sweet potatoes in their natural environment
(Wellness) either, or perhaps they have hidden digging talents. And
peas (Natural Life)! Yes, I always have to shoo the cats away from the
pea-patch, always swiping the pods, the buggers. How about dried kelp
(Newman's Own), doubtless caught be those wily aquacats. Or guar gum
(basically everything). Brown rice, cranberry meal (Felidae). Repeat
to fade.


Touche!

, a lot of the
problems we see today like constipation, diabetes, kidney failure, IBD,
UTI's, etc. would be few.


Big statements - but alas, no big evidence to back 'em up.


Checkmate!

GAUBSTER2 July 18th 04 05:14 AM

From: (Steve G)

Well, Steve, I have to agree with the points you made debating Megan. She
clearly is more interested in ingredients vs. nutrients and is a carbophobic:



Funaba et al. (2001) found that the
digestibility of corn gluten meal and fish
meal were not significantly different. (...)


If I had said corn gluten meal was at issue you might have a slightly
valid point. You don't and have conveniently chosen to ignore the fact
that "hairball remedy" foods contain more than just corn gluten meal.


I see. So, CGM doesn't count even thought it's extracted from corn?
Not sure what your logic is on this one. And *all* cat foods contain
more vegetable or vegetable-derived matter than just CGM.


Another paper by Funaba et al. (2004) [Am J Vet Res 65: 138-142]
suggests that carbs are not optimal, but because they may facilitate
urolith formation, not because the carbs are 'indigestible'.


If cats could indeed digest carbs poorly or not at all, I think that
we wouldn't have quite as many obese (indoor) cats as we do, given the
popularity of dry foods.


Uh oh, you just used logic on Megan!!

Not sure that cats eat sweet potatoes in their natural environment
(Wellness) either, or perhaps they have hidden digging talents. And
peas (Natural Life)! Yes, I always have to shoo the cats away from the
pea-patch, always swiping the pods, the buggers. How about dried kelp
(Newman's Own), doubtless caught be those wily aquacats. Or guar gum
(basically everything). Brown rice, cranberry meal (Felidae). Repeat
to fade.


Touche!

, a lot of the
problems we see today like constipation, diabetes, kidney failure, IBD,
UTI's, etc. would be few.


Big statements - but alas, no big evidence to back 'em up.


Checkmate!

[email protected] July 18th 04 08:11 PM

Gaubster wrote:

From:
Apparently it didn't occur to you that
managing crystals and dissolving them
are two different things.


Of course it did. But you're too busy
putting words into people's mouths to
stop and think, now aren't you?


I did no such thing and I challenge you to prove it.

Let's see what the OP found out:
------------

snip

Looks like they resolved that problem
with the help of the Hill's diets. Once
again, Megan your advice turns out to be
off the mark.


As is typical you use deception to try to win your point (which you
didn't.) You conveniently failed to mention that what the OP wrote about
what was done for his cat and why was posted two days after my post. I
questioned why something was done and he gave me an answer, but here you
are trying to make it look as though he posted that information before I
responded. This is typical of your regular lies and misrepresentations.
It doesn't change the fact that my suggestions for how to treat
constipation and urinary tract issues *are* effective and on the mark.
If a poster takes another approach it doesn't change the validity of
what I say.

...and what research did you do on THIS
particular case?? None, because you
didn't examine the animal personally,
nor did you have access to the cat's
records. Pull your head out, Megan.


I've done plenty of research on how to treat constipation, which is what
this cat had, and have found an approach that works remarkably well
without having to resort to the poor quality prescription foods that so
many vets are brainwashed into recommending. This isn't some incredibly
complicated medical issue and it hasn't been going on for very long. If
the requirement is that we can't give suggestions or advice on health
issues without personally examining the cat or being privy to its
medical records this group would cease to exist. You only put this forth
because you have this pathetic compulsion to be argumentative in spite
of the obvious.

The OP described the results of the cats examination and it's pretty
basic stuff, although compehending basic information is and has for a
long time been above and beyond your abilities.


Again, you're putting words into
people's mouths.


Again, I did no such thing. Prove it or STFU.

Megan



"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do
nothing."

-Edmund Burke

Learn The TRUTH About Declawing
http://www.stopdeclaw.com

Zuzu's Cats Photo Album:
http://www.PictureTrail.com/zuzu22

"Concerning all acts of initiative (and creation), there is one
elementary truth the ignorance of which kills countless ideas and
splendid plans: that the moment one definitely commits oneself, then
providence moves too. A whole stream of events issues from the decision,
raising in one's favor all manner of unforeseen incidents, meetings and
material assistance, which no man could have dreamt would have come his
way."

- W.H. Murray



[email protected] July 18th 04 08:11 PM

Gaubster wrote:

From:
Apparently it didn't occur to you that
managing crystals and dissolving them
are two different things.


Of course it did. But you're too busy
putting words into people's mouths to
stop and think, now aren't you?


I did no such thing and I challenge you to prove it.

Let's see what the OP found out:
------------

snip

Looks like they resolved that problem
with the help of the Hill's diets. Once
again, Megan your advice turns out to be
off the mark.


As is typical you use deception to try to win your point (which you
didn't.) You conveniently failed to mention that what the OP wrote about
what was done for his cat and why was posted two days after my post. I
questioned why something was done and he gave me an answer, but here you
are trying to make it look as though he posted that information before I
responded. This is typical of your regular lies and misrepresentations.
It doesn't change the fact that my suggestions for how to treat
constipation and urinary tract issues *are* effective and on the mark.
If a poster takes another approach it doesn't change the validity of
what I say.

...and what research did you do on THIS
particular case?? None, because you
didn't examine the animal personally,
nor did you have access to the cat's
records. Pull your head out, Megan.


I've done plenty of research on how to treat constipation, which is what
this cat had, and have found an approach that works remarkably well
without having to resort to the poor quality prescription foods that so
many vets are brainwashed into recommending. This isn't some incredibly
complicated medical issue and it hasn't been going on for very long. If
the requirement is that we can't give suggestions or advice on health
issues without personally examining the cat or being privy to its
medical records this group would cease to exist. You only put this forth
because you have this pathetic compulsion to be argumentative in spite
of the obvious.

The OP described the results of the cats examination and it's pretty
basic stuff, although compehending basic information is and has for a
long time been above and beyond your abilities.


Again, you're putting words into
people's mouths.


Again, I did no such thing. Prove it or STFU.

Megan



"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do
nothing."

-Edmund Burke

Learn The TRUTH About Declawing
http://www.stopdeclaw.com

Zuzu's Cats Photo Album:
http://www.PictureTrail.com/zuzu22

"Concerning all acts of initiative (and creation), there is one
elementary truth the ignorance of which kills countless ideas and
splendid plans: that the moment one definitely commits oneself, then
providence moves too. A whole stream of events issues from the decision,
raising in one's favor all manner of unforeseen incidents, meetings and
material assistance, which no man could have dreamt would have come his
way."

- W.H. Murray



[email protected] July 18th 04 09:36 PM

Steve wrote:

If I had said corn gluten meal was at
issue you might have a slightly valid
point. You don't and have conveniently
chosen to ignore the fact that "hairball
remedy" foods contain more than just
corn gluten meal.


I see. So, CGM doesn't count even
thought it's extracted from corn?


Did you go to the Gaubster school of reading comprehension? You're
focusing on corn gluten meal when my point was that that is not the only
ingredient, which you then said yourself:

Not
sure what your logic is on this one. And
*all* cat foods contain more vegetable
or vegetable-derived matter than just
CGM.


Jesus ****ing christ, don't waste my time going off on tangents that
sidestep what I'm talking about then repeat what I said while implying
that I didn't say it.

snip studies Steve hasn't read

Caveat with the above 3 - I've only read
the abstract in each case.


And unless you read them and know the entire content you have no
business using them. You should know better.

If cats could indeed digest carbs poorly
or not at all, I think that we wouldn't
have quite as many obese (indoor) cats
as we do, given the popularity of dry
foods.


From a 2003 AVMA article available at
http://www.catnutrition.org/Catkins.htm:

"Obese cats are four times as likely to develop diabetes mellitus and
five times as likely to develop lameness." Fat cats also have a higher
incidence of non-allergic skin disease, most likely caused by the cat's
inability to clean themselves as effectively, due to their size. This
obesity is most likely the cause of diets with too high a carbohydrate
content.
"Cats are unique in the way they handle protein, carbohydrates, and
fat," Dr. Greco said. Cats are strict carnivores and, because of this,
they have a tremendous ability to produce glucose from protein, but have
difficulty processing carbohydrates. The feline liver has normal
hexokinase activity, but no glucokinase activity. Thus, cats are limited
in their ability to mop up excess glucose and store glycogen. "What
happens is that glucose is going to hang around for a long period of
time," she said, and it eventually becomes fat.
In addition, unlike humans, protein is the stimulus for insulin release
in cats. Cats have adapted to high protein diets by being insulin
resistant. This maintains blood glucose during periods of fasting,
convenient for a cat in the wild, but not so good for pets eating a lot
of carbohydrates.
"When you take an individual that is genetically programmed to consume
high protein and low carbohydrates, and you put them on a high
carbohydrate diet, what happens is their insulin resistance works
against them," she said. "Their blood glucose concentrations are too
high ... they can't overcome that, and they start to release more and
more insulin in an attempt to reduce blood glucose levels." This doesn't
work, however, and the cat eventually develops type 2 diabetes mellitus.
The cat gets amyloid deposition in the pancreas, exhaustion of the
pancreatic cells, and glucose toxicity from consumption of large amounts
of carbohydrates.
So what's Dr. Greco's ideal cat food diet? She recommends a wet food,
high in protein, high in fat, and low in carbohydrates. It's basically a
"CatKins" diet, much like the Atkins diet popular today. This diet is
going to keep a cat slim and help it avoid diabetes.
She recommends a wet cat food because if you are trying to mimic what a
cat eats in the wild, just think of how much water a mouse contains. Wet
cat food is going to give you a pH that is ideal and is, thus, the best
way to prevent feline lower urinary tract inflammation. Dr. Greco said.
In addition, a cat's jaws and teeth are designed for shearing and
tearing meat, and cats that eat dry food grind it in a way that it ends
up between their teeth. There it ferments into sugar and acid, thereby
causing dental problems.
According to Dr. Greco, it all comes down to common sense. "We must use
a cat's natural diet as a guideline."



Not sure that cats eat sweet potatoes in
their natural environment (Wellness)
either, or perhaps they have hidden
digging talents. And peas (Natural
Life)! Yes, I always have to shoo the
cats away from the pea-patch, always
swiping the pods, the buggers. How about
dried kelp (Newman's Own), doubtless
caught be those wily aquacats. Or guar
gum (basically everything). Brown rice,
cranberry meal (Felidae). Repeat to
fade.
Not sure that a cat could bring down a
cow or sheep either, but who's to say
what ambitious felines are out there...


Cats do consume a small amount of vegetable/grain matter that is found
in the stomach of their prey. Canned cat foods are mostly meat with a
small amount of vegetable/grain matter as well. I don't know if you're
just trying to be annoying wit your tangents or what, but the reality is
that if we don't feed a diet of mice then the best we can do is mimic
the content of that type of diet to the best of our ability. If we can't
make it ourselves then we have to rely on the pet food companies and the
choices of ingredients they make, and choose the best of what is
available.

Often they will choose ingredients based on the benefits they offer
rather than because they are eaten by a mouse. And BTW, I have a rat
(which cats will also consume) and he eats peas, rice, sweet potatoes,
raspberries and probably would eat kelp or cranberries if I gave it to
him.

, a lot of the
problems we see today like constipation,
diabetes, kidney failure, IBD, UTI's,
etc. would be few.


Big statements - but alas, no big
evidence to back 'em up.


Not yet, but that doesn't mean it's not a probability. Again, much of
this is a common sense issue. There have already been studies that have
shown dry food can cause or exacerbate urinary tract infections, and I
posted an article above that talks about how a high carbohydrate diet
can cause diabetes. And pay attention to the last line of that article
because it is clear and to the point, and what I said above and have
been saying all along:

*According to Dr. Greco, it all comes down to common sense. "We must use
a cat's natural diet as a guideline." *


Now, I do actually agree with you that
feeding a species appropriate diet is an
appropriate [sic] thing to do,


Yet you have spent much of your post trying to justify the digestibility
of foods that are not fit for a carnivore. You question pet food
companies' use of things like sweet potatoes yet sing the praises of the
digestibility of polenta and corn gluten meal and don't spend one minute
questioning their use.

I really don't have time for this and if you want to argue for the sake
of arguing Gaubster is your man.

but if
you try to justify this by assigning all
manner of ills to carbs - well, there
just ain't the evidence AFAICT. Do you
have any cites?


I did not say "carbs" anywhere in the post you responded to and I
challenge you to show me where I used that term in my post. I said
grains, which is broader and went to my point of residue. You keep on
focusing on digesting and I have responded to that aspect, but I also
specifically said previously that they don't "utilize" them well, which
is verifed in the excerpt of the AVMA article above. You do understand
that digestion is the process of conversion, while utilization is the
process of using that which has been converted, do you not?

Will you now be making justifications
for why a cow should eat meat?


For better or worse, many animals raised
for human consumption are indeed forced
to eat a species inappropriate diet.


And this is a justification? An answer? This was a stupid response on
your part and I expect better of you.

Megan



"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do
nothing."

-Edmund Burke

Learn The TRUTH About Declawing
http://www.stopdeclaw.com

Zuzu's Cats Photo Album:
http://www.PictureTrail.com/zuzu22

"Concerning all acts of initiative (and creation), there is one
elementary truth the ignorance of which kills countless ideas and
splendid plans: that the moment one definitely commits oneself, then
providence moves too. A whole stream of events issues from the decision,
raising in one's favor all manner of unforeseen incidents, meetings and
material assistance, which no man could have dreamt would have come his
way."

- W.H. Murray



[email protected] July 18th 04 09:36 PM

Steve wrote:

If I had said corn gluten meal was at
issue you might have a slightly valid
point. You don't and have conveniently
chosen to ignore the fact that "hairball
remedy" foods contain more than just
corn gluten meal.


I see. So, CGM doesn't count even
thought it's extracted from corn?


Did you go to the Gaubster school of reading comprehension? You're
focusing on corn gluten meal when my point was that that is not the only
ingredient, which you then said yourself:

Not
sure what your logic is on this one. And
*all* cat foods contain more vegetable
or vegetable-derived matter than just
CGM.


Jesus ****ing christ, don't waste my time going off on tangents that
sidestep what I'm talking about then repeat what I said while implying
that I didn't say it.

snip studies Steve hasn't read

Caveat with the above 3 - I've only read
the abstract in each case.


And unless you read them and know the entire content you have no
business using them. You should know better.

If cats could indeed digest carbs poorly
or not at all, I think that we wouldn't
have quite as many obese (indoor) cats
as we do, given the popularity of dry
foods.


From a 2003 AVMA article available at
http://www.catnutrition.org/Catkins.htm:

"Obese cats are four times as likely to develop diabetes mellitus and
five times as likely to develop lameness." Fat cats also have a higher
incidence of non-allergic skin disease, most likely caused by the cat's
inability to clean themselves as effectively, due to their size. This
obesity is most likely the cause of diets with too high a carbohydrate
content.
"Cats are unique in the way they handle protein, carbohydrates, and
fat," Dr. Greco said. Cats are strict carnivores and, because of this,
they have a tremendous ability to produce glucose from protein, but have
difficulty processing carbohydrates. The feline liver has normal
hexokinase activity, but no glucokinase activity. Thus, cats are limited
in their ability to mop up excess glucose and store glycogen. "What
happens is that glucose is going to hang around for a long period of
time," she said, and it eventually becomes fat.
In addition, unlike humans, protein is the stimulus for insulin release
in cats. Cats have adapted to high protein diets by being insulin
resistant. This maintains blood glucose during periods of fasting,
convenient for a cat in the wild, but not so good for pets eating a lot
of carbohydrates.
"When you take an individual that is genetically programmed to consume
high protein and low carbohydrates, and you put them on a high
carbohydrate diet, what happens is their insulin resistance works
against them," she said. "Their blood glucose concentrations are too
high ... they can't overcome that, and they start to release more and
more insulin in an attempt to reduce blood glucose levels." This doesn't
work, however, and the cat eventually develops type 2 diabetes mellitus.
The cat gets amyloid deposition in the pancreas, exhaustion of the
pancreatic cells, and glucose toxicity from consumption of large amounts
of carbohydrates.
So what's Dr. Greco's ideal cat food diet? She recommends a wet food,
high in protein, high in fat, and low in carbohydrates. It's basically a
"CatKins" diet, much like the Atkins diet popular today. This diet is
going to keep a cat slim and help it avoid diabetes.
She recommends a wet cat food because if you are trying to mimic what a
cat eats in the wild, just think of how much water a mouse contains. Wet
cat food is going to give you a pH that is ideal and is, thus, the best
way to prevent feline lower urinary tract inflammation. Dr. Greco said.
In addition, a cat's jaws and teeth are designed for shearing and
tearing meat, and cats that eat dry food grind it in a way that it ends
up between their teeth. There it ferments into sugar and acid, thereby
causing dental problems.
According to Dr. Greco, it all comes down to common sense. "We must use
a cat's natural diet as a guideline."



Not sure that cats eat sweet potatoes in
their natural environment (Wellness)
either, or perhaps they have hidden
digging talents. And peas (Natural
Life)! Yes, I always have to shoo the
cats away from the pea-patch, always
swiping the pods, the buggers. How about
dried kelp (Newman's Own), doubtless
caught be those wily aquacats. Or guar
gum (basically everything). Brown rice,
cranberry meal (Felidae). Repeat to
fade.
Not sure that a cat could bring down a
cow or sheep either, but who's to say
what ambitious felines are out there...


Cats do consume a small amount of vegetable/grain matter that is found
in the stomach of their prey. Canned cat foods are mostly meat with a
small amount of vegetable/grain matter as well. I don't know if you're
just trying to be annoying wit your tangents or what, but the reality is
that if we don't feed a diet of mice then the best we can do is mimic
the content of that type of diet to the best of our ability. If we can't
make it ourselves then we have to rely on the pet food companies and the
choices of ingredients they make, and choose the best of what is
available.

Often they will choose ingredients based on the benefits they offer
rather than because they are eaten by a mouse. And BTW, I have a rat
(which cats will also consume) and he eats peas, rice, sweet potatoes,
raspberries and probably would eat kelp or cranberries if I gave it to
him.

, a lot of the
problems we see today like constipation,
diabetes, kidney failure, IBD, UTI's,
etc. would be few.


Big statements - but alas, no big
evidence to back 'em up.


Not yet, but that doesn't mean it's not a probability. Again, much of
this is a common sense issue. There have already been studies that have
shown dry food can cause or exacerbate urinary tract infections, and I
posted an article above that talks about how a high carbohydrate diet
can cause diabetes. And pay attention to the last line of that article
because it is clear and to the point, and what I said above and have
been saying all along:

*According to Dr. Greco, it all comes down to common sense. "We must use
a cat's natural diet as a guideline." *


Now, I do actually agree with you that
feeding a species appropriate diet is an
appropriate [sic] thing to do,


Yet you have spent much of your post trying to justify the digestibility
of foods that are not fit for a carnivore. You question pet food
companies' use of things like sweet potatoes yet sing the praises of the
digestibility of polenta and corn gluten meal and don't spend one minute
questioning their use.

I really don't have time for this and if you want to argue for the sake
of arguing Gaubster is your man.

but if
you try to justify this by assigning all
manner of ills to carbs - well, there
just ain't the evidence AFAICT. Do you
have any cites?


I did not say "carbs" anywhere in the post you responded to and I
challenge you to show me where I used that term in my post. I said
grains, which is broader and went to my point of residue. You keep on
focusing on digesting and I have responded to that aspect, but I also
specifically said previously that they don't "utilize" them well, which
is verifed in the excerpt of the AVMA article above. You do understand
that digestion is the process of conversion, while utilization is the
process of using that which has been converted, do you not?

Will you now be making justifications
for why a cow should eat meat?


For better or worse, many animals raised
for human consumption are indeed forced
to eat a species inappropriate diet.


And this is a justification? An answer? This was a stupid response on
your part and I expect better of you.

Megan



"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do
nothing."

-Edmund Burke

Learn The TRUTH About Declawing
http://www.stopdeclaw.com

Zuzu's Cats Photo Album:
http://www.PictureTrail.com/zuzu22

"Concerning all acts of initiative (and creation), there is one
elementary truth the ignorance of which kills countless ideas and
splendid plans: that the moment one definitely commits oneself, then
providence moves too. A whole stream of events issues from the decision,
raising in one's favor all manner of unforeseen incidents, meetings and
material assistance, which no man could have dreamt would have come his
way."

- W.H. Murray



GAUBSTER2 July 19th 04 01:12 AM

From:

Apparently it didn't occur to you that
managing crystals and dissolving them
are two different things.


Of course it did. But you're too busy
putting words into people's mouths to
stop and think, now aren't you?


I did no such thing and I challenge you to prove it.


Well, you keep doing it--read on........

Let's see what the OP found out:
------------

snip

Looks like they resolved that problem
with the help of the Hill's diets. Once
again, Megan your advice turns out to be
off the mark.


As is typical you use deception to try to win your point (which you
didn't.) You conveniently failed to mention that what the OP wrote about
what was done for his cat and why was posted two days after my post.


I never made any parallels about time frames (and neither did you for that
matter in your original post). I SAID: Let's see what the OP found out:

Notice the part where I stated, "FOUND OUT". Again, you are trying to twist
things around because your arrogance doesn't allow you to admit when you are
wrong.

Looks like they resolved that problem
with the help of the Hill's diets. Once
again, Megan your advice turns out to be
off the mark.


As is typical you use deception to try to win your point (which you
didn't.)


What part of my above statement is "deceptive"?? It certainly does sound as if
the problem has been resolved with "the help" of Hill's diets. Again, you
should look in the mirror before you start letting the venom flow through your
fingertips.

but here you
are trying to make it look as though he posted that information before I
responded. This is typical of your regular lies and misrepresentations.


Again, you're wrong. I simply stated that what ended up helping his cat was
contrary to what you posted.

I've done plenty of research on how to treat constipation, which is what
this cat had, and have found an approach that works remarkably well
without having to resort to the poor quality prescription foods that so
many vets are brainwashed into recommending.


Right here is where you trip yourself up. The diets his cat were prescribed
were Hill's diets and worked. You don't like Hill's and attempt to convince
other people to listen to you. This particular case is just one example that
you are way off the mark (again). Theraputic diets (especially Hill's) have
been successfully treating millions of pets for almost 60 years. Why you have
a problem with that is beyond me.

Again, I did no such thing. Prove it or STFU.


I gave you one example. I suggest you take your own advice. ;)

GAUBSTER2 July 19th 04 01:12 AM

From:

Apparently it didn't occur to you that
managing crystals and dissolving them
are two different things.


Of course it did. But you're too busy
putting words into people's mouths to
stop and think, now aren't you?


I did no such thing and I challenge you to prove it.


Well, you keep doing it--read on........

Let's see what the OP found out:
------------

snip

Looks like they resolved that problem
with the help of the Hill's diets. Once
again, Megan your advice turns out to be
off the mark.


As is typical you use deception to try to win your point (which you
didn't.) You conveniently failed to mention that what the OP wrote about
what was done for his cat and why was posted two days after my post.


I never made any parallels about time frames (and neither did you for that
matter in your original post). I SAID: Let's see what the OP found out:

Notice the part where I stated, "FOUND OUT". Again, you are trying to twist
things around because your arrogance doesn't allow you to admit when you are
wrong.

Looks like they resolved that problem
with the help of the Hill's diets. Once
again, Megan your advice turns out to be
off the mark.


As is typical you use deception to try to win your point (which you
didn't.)


What part of my above statement is "deceptive"?? It certainly does sound as if
the problem has been resolved with "the help" of Hill's diets. Again, you
should look in the mirror before you start letting the venom flow through your
fingertips.

but here you
are trying to make it look as though he posted that information before I
responded. This is typical of your regular lies and misrepresentations.


Again, you're wrong. I simply stated that what ended up helping his cat was
contrary to what you posted.

I've done plenty of research on how to treat constipation, which is what
this cat had, and have found an approach that works remarkably well
without having to resort to the poor quality prescription foods that so
many vets are brainwashed into recommending.


Right here is where you trip yourself up. The diets his cat were prescribed
were Hill's diets and worked. You don't like Hill's and attempt to convince
other people to listen to you. This particular case is just one example that
you are way off the mark (again). Theraputic diets (especially Hill's) have
been successfully treating millions of pets for almost 60 years. Why you have
a problem with that is beyond me.

Again, I did no such thing. Prove it or STFU.


I gave you one example. I suggest you take your own advice. ;)

GAUBSTER2 July 19th 04 01:20 AM

From:

Why must you treat others with such contempt and derision??

Some examples that you can take full credit for: (and this is just one of
your posts!)

Did you go to the Gaubster school of reading comprehension?


Jesus ****ing christ, don't waste my time going off on tangents that
sidestep what I'm talking about then repeat what I said while implying
that I didn't say it.


Moving on.........

snip studies Steve hasn't read

Caveat with the above 3 - I've only read
the abstract in each case.


And unless you read them and know the entire content you have no
business using them. You should know better.


Have you read those studies, yourself??

If cats could indeed digest carbs poorly
or not at all, I think that we wouldn't
have quite as many obese (indoor) cats
as we do, given the popularity of dry
foods.


You never addressed the logic he put forth. Why not?

You quote extensively from Dr. Greco. Let's see if you are as smart as you
think you are...what food did Dr. Greco base her studies on??

So what's Dr. Greco's ideal cat food diet? She recommends a wet food,
high in protein, high in fat, and low in carbohydrates.


I did not say "carbs" anywhere in the post you responded to and I
challenge you to show me where I used that term in my post. I said
grains,


Where do the majority of carbs come from?? Grains!



GAUBSTER2 July 19th 04 01:20 AM

From:

Why must you treat others with such contempt and derision??

Some examples that you can take full credit for: (and this is just one of
your posts!)

Did you go to the Gaubster school of reading comprehension?


Jesus ****ing christ, don't waste my time going off on tangents that
sidestep what I'm talking about then repeat what I said while implying
that I didn't say it.


Moving on.........

snip studies Steve hasn't read

Caveat with the above 3 - I've only read
the abstract in each case.


And unless you read them and know the entire content you have no
business using them. You should know better.


Have you read those studies, yourself??

If cats could indeed digest carbs poorly
or not at all, I think that we wouldn't
have quite as many obese (indoor) cats
as we do, given the popularity of dry
foods.


You never addressed the logic he put forth. Why not?

You quote extensively from Dr. Greco. Let's see if you are as smart as you
think you are...what food did Dr. Greco base her studies on??

So what's Dr. Greco's ideal cat food diet? She recommends a wet food,
high in protein, high in fat, and low in carbohydrates.


I did not say "carbs" anywhere in the post you responded to and I
challenge you to show me where I used that term in my post. I said
grains,


Where do the majority of carbs come from?? Grains!



[email protected] July 19th 04 04:40 AM


Gaubster wrote:

From:


Apparently it didn't occur to you that
managing crystals and dissolving them
are two different things.


Of course it did. But you're too busy
putting words into people's mouths to
stop and think, now aren't you?


I did no such thing and I challenge you
to prove it.


Well, you keep doing it--read on........



Let's see what the OP found out:
------------

Looks like they resolved that problem
with the help of the Hill's diets. Once
again, Megan your advice turns out to be
off the mark.


As is typical you use deception to try
to win your point (which you didn't.)
You conveniently failed to mention that
what the OP wrote about what was done
for his cat and why was posted two days
after my post.


I never made any parallels about time
frames (and neither did you for that
matter in your original post). I SAID:


Let's see what the OP found out:


Notice the part where I stated, "FOUND
OUT". Again, you are trying to twist
things around because your arrogance
doesn't allow you to admit when you are
wrong.


No, not at all. You implied, it's obvious and trying to backpedal
doesn't change reality.

Looks like they resolved that problem
with the help of the Hill's diets. Once
again, Megan your advice turns out to be
off the mark.


As is typical you use deception to try
to win your point (which you didn't.)


What part of my above statement is
"deceptive"?? It certainly does sound as
if the problem has been resolved with
"the help" of Hill's diets. Again, you
should look in the mirror before you
start letting the venom flow through
your fingertips.


You implied I should have already known what was done for the cat by
following it with the statement that my advice was off the mark. You
also implied that because the Hill's diet worked, my advice was wrong.
It was not. You know exactly what you did, it was deceptive, and this is
typical of you.

I've done plenty of research on how to
treat constipation, which is what this
cat had, and have found an approach that
works remarkably well without having to
resort to the poor quality prescription
foods that so many vets are brainwashed
into recommending.


Right here is where you trip yourself
up.


Not at all. I have made similar statements in the past and am
consistent.

The diets his cat were prescribed
were Hill's diets and worked. You don't
like Hill's and attempt to convince
other people to listen to you.


No, you're wrong. I care about the health of cats and think it's better
to treat issues with a proper species appropriate diet rather than
depend on low quality prescription foods. It doesn't matter who makes
it.

This
particular case is just one example that
you are way off the mark (again).


No, you're wrong, because I've seen cats completely cured from having
constipation simply by changing their food to a high quality canned
diet. There are also hundreds of others on the IBD list alone that have
resolved constipation, diarrhea and IBD issues not by feeding
prescription diets, but by feeding foods that are as close to what a cat
would eat naturally as they can reasonably get. There are certainly
countless others that have been successful using a proper diet instead
of prescription foods as well. This is not rocket science and this
approach is not by any means off the mark. It's an approach that is, in
the article I posted, recommended by a veterinary internal medicine
specialist and published by the AVMA, but I'm sure that since she
doesn't work for or recommend Hill's you'll claim she's wrong too.

Theraputic diets (especially Hill's)
have been successfully treating millions
of pets for almost 60 years.


And I have successfully treated many health issues without having to use
prescription diets, even though they were recommended. So have countless
others.

Why you
have a problem with that is beyond me.


Because their food is low quality crap, full of grains and often
undefined meat sources, with a high price tag. The fact that you have a
problem with successfully treating constipation issues by feeding a high
quality canned food rather than a prescription diet is just more proof
that you are a shill for Hills.

Again, I did no such thing. Prove it or
STFU.


I gave you one example.


No, you didn't. You didn't post one quote that proved I "put words in
your mouth." In fact, in the glaringly erroneous example you used I
clearly stated that you "failed to mention." That means that you
*didn't* say something and can in no way, shape or form be called
"putting words in your mouth."

Megan



"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do
nothing."

-Edmund Burke

Learn The TRUTH About Declawing
http://www.stopdeclaw.com

Zuzu's Cats Photo Album:
http://www.PictureTrail.com/zuzu22

"Concerning all acts of initiative (and creation), there is one
elementary truth the ignorance of which kills countless ideas and
splendid plans: that the moment one definitely commits oneself, then
providence moves too. A whole stream of events issues from the decision,
raising in one's favor all manner of unforeseen incidents, meetings and
material assistance, which no man could have dreamt would have come his
way."

- W.H. Murray




All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:37 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
CatBanter.com