In article ,
enlightened us with... And hey, I have lived out in the country, 10 miles from a very *small* town. Nearest neighbor over 2 miles away. Still doesn't mean they can't get hit by a car coming up the driveway. So can your dog or a child (yours or someone else's visiting, etc) if the person driving up YOUR driveway is a moron. My cat could get on my 'fridge and jump off and break a leg, too, but I don't stop her from going up there. At what point do we draw the line for risks? (I know where MINE is; I'm asking rather generally) At what point does it stop becoming our fault that a creature in our care was hurt? If I let my cat climb on my counters and she falls and hurts herself, is it my fault for letting her up there? If I let her in MY yard and some idiot comes jamming up the drive and hits her, is it my fault or theirs? Just a general question for thought -- people will have differing opinions on this one, I'm sure. -- -- ~kaeli~ What's another word for thesaurus? http://www.ipwebdesign.net/wildAtHeart http://www.ipwebdesign.net/kaelisSpace |
"Mary" wrote in message ... SNIP Nonsense. You are neglecting your responsibilities to your pets. Those of us who keep them indoors are not. It's very simple. Having seen many animals maimed and killed by cars etc., I and others feel strongly about this. You are wrong for endangering the animals that trust you. If you felt your cats were irreplaceable you would not endanger them. No venom in that. What you hate, and others who are equally irresponsible hate, is being reminded of what you are really doing when you let them out unattended. For your cats' sakes, you should be reminded. The "venom" as you put it, is on your side. Do you let your kids out, or keep them indoors all day as well? |
"Meghan Noecker" wrote in message ... On Tue, 05 Apr 2005 03:01:55 GMT, "Mathew Kagis" And hey, I have lived out in the country, 10 miles from a very *small* town. Nearest neighbor over 2 miles away. Still doesn't mean they can't get hit by a car coming up the driveway. Is your cat stuffed, or can it move? How often does a car come up your driveway? If you want to risk your cat's lives, that's your problem. But it is really frustrating when most people who complain their cat was hit by a car are people who let the cat out in the first place. Very few are accidental escapes. Most could have been prevented easily. Any animal can survive incarceration, but we recognise now that zoos are cruel. Cats are predators who should be allowed out to explore and enjoy life. |
"Phil P." wrote in message ... Peter Neville, *British* world renowned feline behaviorist: "The human/cat relationship is based on many, often contrasting factors. Indoors the cat is valued for its cleanliness, affection and playfulness, and admired for its highly evolved play behaviour. Although not a group hunter, the cat retains an enormous capacity to be sociable and accepts the benefits of living in the human family and den without compromising its self-determining and independent behaviour. Bristol University, Department of Veterinary Medicine, Langford House, Langford, Avon BS18 7DU, UK (Excerpted from: Handbook of Feline Medicine, Willis J, Wolf A; Pergamon Press, Oxford OX3 OBW, England) BSAVA; and Manual of Feline Behaviour, British Small Animal Veterinary Association, Kingsley House. Church Lane. Shurdington, Cheltenham. Gloucestershire GL51 5TQ Dr. Nicholas Dodman, *British*, and the Director of the Behavior Clinic at Tufts University School of Veterinary Medicine and internationally known specialist in domestic animal behavioral research, states "Its a lot safer to keep cats indoors. The average lifespan of an indoor cat is around twelve to fourteen years, while outdoor cats are lucky to reach double digits. I personally have lost three cats prematurely to trauma over the past fifteen years. Two were struck by vehicles on a fairly quiet road, and the other was killed by a roaming neighborhood dog. Because of experiences like this I have certainly had cause to think long and hard about letting future cats out. At present, our cats remain indoors where they're safest" (Excerpted from the Cat Who Cried for Help). "The hazards of the outdoors-automobiles, dogs, rival cats, poisonous plants, infectious diseases, and fleas, to name but a few-are compelling reasons to keep cats exclusively indoors. It is especially important to keep declawed cats indoors, as they are poorly equipped to defend themselves or escape danger by climbing trees. Indoor cats are unquestionably safer and healthier than outdoor cats, and they make better household pets. They don't endanger birds and other wildlife or bring home fleas or dead animals, nor do they need frequent visits to the veterinarian to treat injuries sustained in scraps with rival cats. Screened-in porches or specially constructed window enclosures allow indoor-only cats to sniff the fresh air, peruse the goings-on outside, and bask in the sun. By regularly changing the indoor environment, you can help keep your cat challenged-; strategically situated empty cardboard boxes or plain brown shopping bags (minus the handles) can provide an old space with new interest." Dr. James Richards, Director, Cornell Feline Health Center: "Cats can be happily kept inside all the time. Many people do so and would have it no other way. They say they have deeper and more satisfying relationships with their cats and that those cats are healthier and live longer. While living happily inside, cats are not getting hit by cars, being injured in cat fights, catching infections such as feline leukemia virus and feline immunodeficiency virus (Feline "AIDS"), being stolen, hunting and possibly killing wildlife, urinating and defecating on neighbors' properties, and harassing or being harassed by other animals. Clearly there are many good reasons for permanently keeping cats indoors." Robert J. Holmes, BVM&S, PhD, MRCVS, FACVSc, Animal Behaviour Clinic, Malvern Vie 3 144, *Australia*. Excerpted from Cat Behavior and Training. "Many cats born as strays and adopted as housecats adjust remarkably quickly. Indeed, many stray cats that are adopted remain indoors permanently without protest. Cats that live in temperate climates may naturally restrict their outdoor activity during cold winter months. These individuals may adapt more readily to being kept indoors permanently. Provide a wide variety of toys that are attractive to your cat (not just to you). Frequently play with your young cat so that it is less prone to seek amusement elsewhere. It is particularly important to provide your cat with additional outlets by playing with it and engaging in interactive diversions you both will enjoy. Have your cat neutered at an appropriate age as recommended by your veterinarian. Although territorial roaming provides cats with exercise and mental stimulation, cats can live a happy life while remaining indoors. The risk of injury (from motor vehicle accidents, cat fights, or confrontations with other animals), disease, and abuse far outweigh any possible benefit to your cat. It is not cruel to restrict cats to an exclusively indoor existence. Rather, the cruelty lies in exposing them to the dangers outside of a safe home." Dr. Stefanie Schwartz, DVM, MSc,DACVB, Diplomate, American College of Veterinary Behaviorists Director of Behavior Services, VCA South Shore Animal Hospital, So. Weymouth, MA Clin. Asst. Prof., Tufts University School of Veterinary Medicine. Replace 'cat' with 'kids' - makes perfect sense. |
Phil P. wrote: "Ashley" wrote in message ... (...) What Phil did was post a selective list of vets he agrees who back up his world view That's exactly what you did you ****ing moron! It's easy to post vet or other 'authorative' sources to support either viewpoint. This is because there is no universal agreement as to whether cats should have outdoor access or not. In particular in places outside the US, more (most) vets will suggest cats have outdoor access. Not to mention the views of posters in this group are not necessarily representative of views in the US as a whole. Steve. |
Mary wrote: (...) Nonsense. You are neglecting your responsibilities to your pets. Those of us who keep them indoors are not. (...) You are wrong for endangering the animals that trust you. But letting your indoor cat become grossly obese is OK - or do you only count outdoor dangers in your tirade? Or any dangers *you* expose your cats to don't count? If you felt your cats were irreplaceable you would not endanger them. No venom in that. What you hate, and others who are equally irresponsible hate, is being reminded of what you are really doing when you let them out unattended. Ah, so all cat owners in the UK and NZ - yes, their cats are simply disposible objects. All 50 million or so. And the crusade and the xenophobia roll on... Steve. |
|
|
"ceb" wrote in message ... (Meghan Noecker) wrote in news:d2t87m$o97$1 : If you want to risk your cat's lives, that's your problem. But it is really frustrating when most people who complain their cat was hit by a car are people who let the cat out in the first place. Very few are accidental escapes. Most could have been prevented easily. Really? I don't find it hard to sympathize with people who have lost their pets due to an accident. People who knowingly put their animals at risk do NOT deserve my sympathy--particularly those idiotic enough to argue with people who love their cats enough to keep them inside, and then expect sympathy when wahh wahhh, fluffy got squashed or mauled or poisoned or stolen. What a crock of horse ****. Take responsibility for your actions. |
All times are GMT +1. The time now is 01:20 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
CatBanter.com