Other alternatives to Hills prescription s/d?

Let's try this - ZUZU why don't you pick one ingredient you think is
"crap" then show us the peer reviewed published data that supports your
opinion that this particular ingredient is crap. Let's see if you can
prove your own thesis.

"Steve Crane" wrote in message
ups.com...
Let's try this - ZUZU why don't you pick one ingredient you think is
"crap" then show us the peer reviewed published data that supports your
opinion that this particular ingredient is crap. Let's see if you can
prove your own thesis.


This sounds like a great idea.

Steve Crane wrote:
snip expected bull****

Nice try at scaring people away from what is working for them. Hopefully
they'll see you have a financial interest in everything you post, look
at your lies with a critical eye, and ignore the scamming you do.

And BTW, Wellness does tell you the ph range for their foods. Call them
and ask. I did.

Megan



"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do
nothing."

-Edmund Burke

Learn The TRUTH About Declawing
http://www.stopdeclaw.com

Zuzu's Cats Photo Album:
http://www.PictureTrail.com/zuzu22

"Concerning all acts of initiative (and creation), there is one
elementary truth the ignorance of which kills countless ideas and
splendid plans: that the moment one definitely commits oneself, then
providence moves too. A whole stream of events issues from the decision,
raising in one's favor all manner of unforeseen incidents, meetings and
material assistance, which no man could have dreamt would have come his
way."

- W.H. Murray

Steve Crane wrote:
Let's try this - ZUZU why don't you pick
one ingredient you think is "crap" then
show us the peer reviewed published data
that supports your opinion that this
particular ingredient is crap.

Here you go again with your BS. You don't need a "peer reviewed" study
to know if something is crap. Do *you* need one to know **** is crap?
Probably. Ingredients have been discussed here over and over and
claiming a cat can "tolerate" corn, soybean mill run, ethoxyquin and
other garbage you put in pet food doesn't mean it should be in there or
that it is species appropriate. You can do all the smoke and mirrors you
want. Smart people see right through you. Oh and while you're at it,
we're still waiting for you to answer the question equalizer put to you
asking if Hill's, who claims they don't do animal testing, uses/pays
outside sources to do animal testing.

Megan



"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do
nothing."

-Edmund Burke

Learn The TRUTH About Declawing
http://www.stopdeclaw.com

Zuzu's Cats Photo Album:
http://www.PictureTrail.com/zuzu22

"Concerning all acts of initiative (and creation), there is one
elementary truth the ignorance of which kills countless ideas and
splendid plans: that the moment one definitely commits oneself, then
providence moves too. A whole stream of events issues from the decision,
raising in one's favor all manner of unforeseen incidents, meetings and
material assistance, which no man could have dreamt would have come his
way."

- W.H. Murray

wrote in message
...
Steve Crane wrote:
Let's try this - ZUZU why don't you pick
one ingredient you think is "crap" then
show us the peer reviewed published data
that supports your opinion that this
particular ingredient is crap.

Here you go again with your BS. You don't need a "peer reviewed" study
to know if something is crap. Do *you* need one to know **** is crap?
Probably. Ingredients have been discussed here over and over and
claiming a cat can "tolerate" corn, soybean mill run, ethoxyquin and
other garbage you put in pet food doesn't mean it should be in there or
that it is species appropriate. You can do all the smoke and mirrors you
want. Smart people see right through you. Oh and while you're at it,
we're still waiting for you to answer the question equalizer put to you
asking if Hill's, who claims they don't do animal testing, uses/pays
outside sources to do animal testing.

Megan



This is precisely how I expected you to answer.

OK ZUZU
Let's just concentrate on ingredinet at a time. You claim:

Here you go again with your BS. You don't need a "peer reviewed" study

to know if something is crap. Do *you* need one to know **** is crap?
Probably. Ingredients have been discussed here over and over and
claiming a cat can "tolerate" corn

Now you've made the claim - now prove that corn is "bad" for cats. Show
us the scientific proof that corn has any deleterious effects on cats.
Show us any clinical trial or any kind which proves your point.

And yes you do need more than just wacko internet fantasy opinions to
"know if something is crap" otherwise is it nothing but whacko ideas,
internet fantasies, and purely erroneous emotional judgements.

Now - prove your claims or admit you haven't got a clue about feline
nutrition. Your choice.

"Steve Crane" wrote in message
oups.com...
OK ZUZU
Let's just concentrate on ingredinet at a time. You claim:

Here you go again with your BS. You don't need a "peer reviewed" study

to know if something is crap. Do *you* need one to know **** is crap?
Probably. Ingredients have been discussed here over and over and
claiming a cat can "tolerate" corn

Now you've made the claim - now prove that corn is "bad" for cats. Show
us the scientific proof that corn has any deleterious effects on cats.
Show us any clinical trial or any kind which proves your point.

And yes you do need more than just wacko internet fantasy opinions to
"know if something is crap" otherwise is it nothing but whacko ideas,
internet fantasies, and purely erroneous emotional judgements.

Now - prove your claims or admit you haven't got a clue about feline
nutrition. Your choice.


Steve, the science behind Megan's "expertise" is very complicated.
Let me sum it up for you. "Meat good. Everything else bad."
Granted, it may be true. But that is as complicated as it gets.

wrote:
Steve Crane wrote:
snip expected bull****

Nice try at scaring people away from what is working for them.
Hopefully
they'll see you have a financial interest in everything you post,
look
at your lies with a critical eye, and ignore the scamming you do.

Megan, are you some lonely old spinster w/ a bunch of cats that is so
withdrawn from society that you've let you hatred and bitterness
consume you?? Your venom is not neccessary here just because someone
doesn't agree w/ you!

You are a Hill's Hater and a proponent of OMH Wellness which does
exactly ZERO research into small animal clinical nutrition. You're one
of those ignorant people who doesn't believe facts and science, you buy
into emotion only and when someone doesn't agree with you, or questions
you in any way, you attack them. Why?

wrote:
Steve Crane wrote:
Let's try this - ZUZU why don't you pick
one ingredient you think is "crap" then
show us the peer reviewed published data
that supports your opinion that this
particular ingredient is crap.

Here you go again with your BS. You don't need a "peer reviewed"
study
to know if something is crap.

You're commenting on something that is subjective. Your OPINION
doesn't hold much sway over the FACTS.

Do *you* need one to know **** is crap?
Probably. Ingredients have been discussed here over and over and
claiming a cat can "tolerate" corn, soybean mill run, ethoxyquin and
other garbage you put in pet food doesn't mean it should be in there
or
that it is species appropriate.

Those things aren't neccessarily "garbage". Can you show us any
peer-reviewed published research that proves your OPINION? I didn't
think you could.

" wrote in message
oups.com...

wrote:
Steve Crane wrote:
snip expected bull****

Nice try at scaring people away from what is working for them.
Hopefully
they'll see you have a financial interest in everything you post,
look
at your lies with a critical eye, and ignore the scamming you do.

Megan, are you some lonely old spinster w/ a bunch of cats that is so
withdrawn from society that you've let you hatred and bitterness
consume you?? Your venom is not neccessary here just because someone
doesn't agree w/ you!

She does do this but ad hominem attacks make you just as bad as she
is. She sucks me into this kind of behavior on a regular basis. And she's
got Brian Link and others doing the same thing. It may be unavoidable
in such a public forum, but it doesn't contribute much to the discussion.