If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
FDA to rethink animal feed rule due to mad cow
|
#2
|
|||
|
|||
If cows aren't supposed to eat meat products, then why would farms feed them
meat products? Especially if a healthy cow would be a desirable way to make money? Are you saying owners of cows don't want them to be healthy and so they are fed things they aren't meant to eat? This smells like a new conspiracy! Do you *honestly* think feedlot cattle producers *care* about healthy cattle, or producing meat that's healthy to consume? They care about *pounds*. More pounds on the hoof equals more money. Sherry |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
If cows aren't supposed to eat meat products, then why would farms feed them
meat products? Especially if a healthy cow would be a desirable way to make money? Are you saying owners of cows don't want them to be healthy and so they are fed things they aren't meant to eat? This smells like a new conspiracy! Do you *honestly* think feedlot cattle producers *care* about healthy cattle, or producing meat that's healthy to consume? They care about *pounds*. More pounds on the hoof equals more money. Sherry |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
If cows aren't supposed to eat meat products, then why would farms feed them
meat products? Because garbage is cheap. I said meat products, not garbage. Especially if a healthy cow would be a desirable way to make money? They figure their customers are too stupid to know the difference. In some cases, of course, they're right. Sorry, your answers just don't add up. Based on your answers, it seems that you don't have much knowledge of the meat industry? |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
If cows aren't supposed to eat meat products, then why would farms feed them
meat products? Because garbage is cheap. I said meat products, not garbage. Especially if a healthy cow would be a desirable way to make money? They figure their customers are too stupid to know the difference. In some cases, of course, they're right. Sorry, your answers just don't add up. Based on your answers, it seems that you don't have much knowledge of the meat industry? |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
|
#7
|
|||
|
|||
|
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Sherry wrote:
If cows aren't supposed to eat meat products, then why would farms feed them meat products? Especially if a healthy cow would be a desirable way to make money? Are you saying owners of cows don't want them to be healthy and so they are fed things they aren't meant to eat? This smells like a new conspiracy! Do you *honestly* think feedlot cattle producers *care* about healthy cattle, or producing meat that's healthy to consume? They care about *pounds*. More pounds on the hoof equals more money. Sherry Yes, to back you up - and as I've posted recently - only since 1997 has cattle and sheep protein been banned from cattle feed. And it was only banned because of MCD, not because they decided it wasn't suitable for a ruminant to eat animal protein. it's still allowed in poultry and pig feed, though... |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Sherry wrote:
If cows aren't supposed to eat meat products, then why would farms feed them meat products? Especially if a healthy cow would be a desirable way to make money? Are you saying owners of cows don't want them to be healthy and so they are fed things they aren't meant to eat? This smells like a new conspiracy! Do you *honestly* think feedlot cattle producers *care* about healthy cattle, or producing meat that's healthy to consume? They care about *pounds*. More pounds on the hoof equals more money. Sherry Yes, to back you up - and as I've posted recently - only since 1997 has cattle and sheep protein been banned from cattle feed. And it was only banned because of MCD, not because they decided it wasn't suitable for a ruminant to eat animal protein. it's still allowed in poultry and pig feed, though... |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Sherry, don't you think that cattle producers care about their product (could
mean more profit)? I read in a newstory elsewhere that it is a common practice to feed meat to cattle from other animals because it fattens them up. Yes, it's common practice because it's a cheap additive to the feed. This is just my opinion, but I don't think the big feedlot producers care about anything except the dollars. And the feed mills are right behind them, putting all kinds of chemicals and drugs and additives in the feed to *help* put those pounds on. Putting more pounds on the animal at the highest profit is the name of the game, not necessarily what's good for the animal or good for the person who consumes the meat. Cattle are herbivores. Feeding them meat products is a practice designed for the good of the seller, not the consumer or the animal. I'd be interested in hearing what your dairy farm friend says. The family farm - type operations are a different ball game altogether, IMO. The cattle are usually treated much better altogether, and although they still are fed the same feed, at least it's supplemented by hay or pasture grazing. Cattle will eat anything, BTW. If you don't take the feed sack away from them, they'll eat that too. On the other hand, there are cattle ranchers who don't supplement feed at all during the winter, and they justify the normal winter weight loss (pounds=dollars, remember) by the money they've saved on feed. Cattle are really dumb creatures, but even cows deserve a better shake than some of them get, IMO. Sherry Sherry Apparently, (according to the story) there is nothing wrong w/ that? Again, it would be interesting to hear from people w/ actual experience in this industry. I do have a friend that I haven't talked to in a few months that grew up on a dairy farm--I'll have to see what she says. |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
FDA to rethink animal feed rule due to mad cow | Steve | Cat health & behaviour | 38 | December 29th 03 11:26 PM |